1177 B. C.

This book was informative but proved to be a frustrating read. Historian Eric Cline presents a detail assessment of the complex factors at play which led to the collapse of the Late Bronze Age, an early interconnected “global” system that included Mycenaean Greece, New Kingdom Egypt, the Hittites, Canaanites, Assyrians, and others. This system was connected through trade in tin and copper (required to smelt bronze) across the Eastern Mediterranean.

What I found frustrating was Cline’s tendency to repeat himself through the work. Many of the chapters are arbitrarily divided into numerous subheadings or, rather than taking a sweeping thematic approach, present a plethora of case-by-case studies that inevitably repeat some information. I’ve generally found this type of “ancient” history incredibly frustrating. The fact that we lack a wealth of extant source materials inevitably leads to the hedging of interpretation (Well, we don’t know this; It could have been this, or that, or this, or that) with most historians afraid to take a leap of faith and present the most plausible narrative. That was the case in this volume. I kept wanting Cline to provide a straightforward, coherent narrative that explained this systems collapse with it being implied that all interpretation is subject to change at the availability of new material. Instead, only the last chapter details the “collapse” and, even then, with an enormous amount of hedging and hand-wringing.

This is a hard book to write as a conscientious historian. There is a lot of circumstantial evidence that the complexity and interconnectedness of the mediterranean societies fell around the year in the century around 1177 BC, but the clues for what caused it is scarce. So to write a book about it enjoyable to a laymen seem quite hard to me as it is hard to write a clear and coherent narrative of the event.

Cline's solution is to write a bit about the archaeological discoveries of Troy and the graves of Egyptian pharaohs, write a lot about the centuries leading up to 1177 BC and end the book with a chapter discussing different theories on why the collapse happened. The passages about the archeological discoveries feels unnecessary and there just as page fillers, the exposition of the centuries leading up to 1177 BC is necessary to show the complexity and interconnectedness of the societies but feels at times quite excessive (for example is it seldom the details about dynastical changes in Egypt feel relevant to the question of the collapse) and the last part about why the collapse happened is to short.

If you have a general interest in late bronze age societies around the Mediterranean the book is definitely worth a read as it describes the connections between societies in the region to some extent. If you are more interested in the details of a particular bronze age societies there is without a doubt better books out there. If you are like me interested in what the title of the book promises (that is a discussion of the collapse of societies around 1177 BC) you may skip the first four chapters and go straight away to the fifth, and last, chapter.

Somehow, in mid-January 2017 I watched Dr Eric Cline’s lecture to the famed Oriental Institute at the University of Chicago on February 25, 2015.

It was really great—you know how some books and some topics, an author can satisfy all your curiosity in an hour-long talk? There was some risk of that with this talk, but my wonderful library system delivered an audiobook version of this book narrated by Andy Caploe, who must have gotten some instruction in the pronunciation of Late Bronze Age names like Suppiluliuma the Hittite king, Burna-Buriash the Kassite-Babylonian king, and Shutruk-Nahhunte the Elamite because it was wonderful to hear these names and now be able to pronounce them.

I am so happy I was able to go through the entire book because of the details are absolutely fascinating and gorgeously-presented. Cline emphasizes in the beginning that it’s important to understand what collapsed circa 1177 BCE, and spends the majority of the book doing that, thereby painting a beautiful portrait of flowing international goods, culture, letters, royal spouses, and more between Egypt, the Mitanni, the Hittites, the Mycenaeans, Crete and Cypress, Canaan, Babylonia, Libya, Nubia, and more. Spending a few days immersed in our reconstruction of this cosmopolitan world was a moving experience for me.

A smaller part of the book details not so much the collapse as how we can know anything about what ended it all, the specific archaeological details that were pieced together to get that picture, and the way people have understood the collapse over the years. This part is also fantastic. Far too many history books and podcasts summarize the results of archaeological or textual analysis without getting into the gritty details of what constituted that analysis.

My favorite example of Cline’s detailed exposition of specific archaeological excavations is when he discussed the Uluburun and Cape Gelidonya shipwrecks (which went down sometime in the 1200s and 1300s) excavated by George Bass, whose team invented underwater archaeology. Cline gave enough juicy details about the excavations here that I was moved to get my hands on George Bass’ “A History of Seafaring”, a large and well-illustrated book that was alas published before the Uluburun wreck was first discovered by (get this) a sponge diver but after the field was well-established by Bass and his colleagues.

The last part of the book is about why, and as the least interesting, most fluid, and most unknowable part of the whole story, thankfully occupies the least space. Cline says it in more words, but the reason why this cosmopolitan urban world order collapsed is because, well, shit happens.

Finally, I’ll share my hot tip for successful audiobook consumption. I usually don’t do audiobooks these days because I drive, and I can’t take notes during a drive. However, I managed to borrow the ebook as well as the audiobook, and thankfully my work and family duties are relaxed enough that I’m able to spend a few minutes after arriving at my destination to skim the parts I just listened to on my ebook reader to make notes and highlight the most striking points. This way, I got the best of both worlds—excellent pronunciation guidance and a dramatic reading, as well as an annotated text.

I am really looking forward to Dr Cline’s forthcoming book, “Digging Up Armageddon” about the history and archaeology of Megiddo, where twenty cities have been found, built over three thousand years! If you’re on Twitter, it’s worth following him.