charlag reviewed The Autobiography of Malcolm X by Walter Dean Myers
Thinking in Motion
5 stars
…like Michael E. Sawyer called it.
This is a great book. It is, first of all, well written. I don't know if it's been edited this way but the story of Malcolm, especially early days, reads like a good novel, not like a biography. It is important to understand: it is not all written from one point of time. In the time the book was written a lot has changed. What you read early on does not represent what Malcolm thought later on, as we learn from unedited (by Malcolm) account by Alex Haley, which is one of the most interesting parts. first you read the book and then you learn things from a very different perspective and suddenly a person forms out of this novel-like story. I really liked that. Having said that, there is a lot of mysoginy and antisemitism, as well as other flaws. It is …
…like Michael E. Sawyer called it.
This is a great book. It is, first of all, well written. I don't know if it's been edited this way but the story of Malcolm, especially early days, reads like a good novel, not like a biography. It is important to understand: it is not all written from one point of time. In the time the book was written a lot has changed. What you read early on does not represent what Malcolm thought later on, as we learn from unedited (by Malcolm) account by Alex Haley, which is one of the most interesting parts. first you read the book and then you learn things from a very different perspective and suddenly a person forms out of this novel-like story. I really liked that. Having said that, there is a lot of mysoginy and antisemitism, as well as other flaws. It is impossible to tell if Malcolm changed his mind on some of those things, like he did with others. It is important to remember where Malcolm came from, which standards we hold him to and also which Malcolm, that is, at which point of his development. He was a real person with flaws and changing views, which he was first to admit. One could say that the account of his life is more important for understanding racism, civil rights movement and USA than any single theory on its own.