VEMPHaHa reviewed My grandmother's hands by Resmaa Menakem
Review of "My grandmother's hands" on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
When I got to the puppy paragraph (if you've read the book, you know what I'm talking about), the author recommended you put the book down for half an hour or so. I put it down for 5 months. The description and reasoning behind it rely on a theory I developed on my own as a result of abuse: if you watch a steel beam fall on a child's head, you have trauma, even though it wasn't your head crushed. Still. I hated the manipulation of this paragraph. The same way movies use cutie-cutie animals and kids and innocents to draw you in then--bam! They hurt them.
Why am I focusing on this paragraph? Because I don't understand the creation of additional cellular trauma in the service of explaining the retention of cellular trauma. So, yes, I agree with the author's premise that we retain and pass down generational trauma. …
When I got to the puppy paragraph (if you've read the book, you know what I'm talking about), the author recommended you put the book down for half an hour or so. I put it down for 5 months. The description and reasoning behind it rely on a theory I developed on my own as a result of abuse: if you watch a steel beam fall on a child's head, you have trauma, even though it wasn't your head crushed. Still. I hated the manipulation of this paragraph. The same way movies use cutie-cutie animals and kids and innocents to draw you in then--bam! They hurt them.
Why am I focusing on this paragraph? Because I don't understand the creation of additional cellular trauma in the service of explaining the retention of cellular trauma. So, yes, I agree with the author's premise that we retain and pass down generational trauma. And I find his suggested steps for interrupting the "lizard brain" reaction to racial situations spot on. Plus, his vision of white people creating a new culture totally meshes with my view of how my home state needs to 100% revise its original story. Hence, the 4 star review.
But if he truly believes in retained trauma—his core premise—how could he be a participant in creating more? That willingness, near the end of the book, shook my confidence in the author. So, no vouching here. Just a book review. Other than that, you're on your own.