Paperback, 480 pages
English language
Published March 26, 2008 by Orbit.
Consider Phlebas is perhaps one of the lesser-known, but nevertheless the first, of the revelationary late Iain M. Banks' science fiction books. Consider Phlebas introduces us to the complex world of the mind-controlling, ubiquitous utopia of the Culture, which contrasts to their mortal sentient enemies. Iain Banks creates an imaginative and encapsulating premise to keep the reader hooked for more, with hints of science fiction and alien humour to liven a deadly race against an omnipotent foe.
I’ve always heard the culture described as the “good guys”, so the perspective of an outsider was intriguing. I also appreciated the cynicism that the cultures enemies approached it with. I’d given up on science fiction because I’d grown to associate it with YA pulp, but Banks drew me back in.
This one introduced me to the Culture and got me hooked. It's a crazy and bloody adventure in a weird space opera setting, featuring a quirky crew that get's picked off one by one.
Lot's of new ideas and story elements (for me), so I enjoyed it. What stood out the most was how the author painted this, supposedly, "wonderful utopia" of the Culture as the Bad Guys and the protagonist's struggles against them.
3 stars for worldbuilding in the first half 1 star for generic and cliche characters (especially female characters)
also (south park voice) "this is what tech accelerationists actually believe"
I guess I expected more… There’s one chapter (the eaters) that you can just skip completly imo. There’s been several times when I just wanted to stop reading (the eater-chapter and gendered stereotypes that continue to exist unchanged in the far future…), but I kept going for some reason and have not been rewarded.
This book had been on my list for a while and I was excited to read it.
The ‘universe’ building was great and it definitely inspires me to read more of the series. The plot of this book wasn’t quite what I expected and at times seemed to drift from the main thread to fill in the timeline. That said it comes together in the end.
Interesting enough for me to read the next book but, in general, it was a bit of a slog
This was my first reading of Consider Phlebas, and it felt odd to ponder that it's the first of the Culture books. In particular: if this had been my first exposure to Banks, I'm not sure I would have had a second. This is a very, very weird sensation! It's not that my life would feel hollow—for how would I know—but the Me who has read the Culture books shudders to think of a Me who hasn't.
It's a decent book, and offers glimpses of the writer Banks is to be, but it's just, well, off somehow. Too-pat characters. Too many improbable coincidences. Too shallow, too preachy. So weird, in fact, that I've waited almost a month to write this review. I had to wait to read another Banks ([b:The Player of Games|18630|The Player of Games (Culture, #2)|Iain M. Banks|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1166984450s/18630.jpg|1494157]) to restore my balance.
If you're a Banks fan you'll …
This was my first reading of Consider Phlebas, and it felt odd to ponder that it's the first of the Culture books. In particular: if this had been my first exposure to Banks, I'm not sure I would have had a second. This is a very, very weird sensation! It's not that my life would feel hollow—for how would I know—but the Me who has read the Culture books shudders to think of a Me who hasn't.
It's a decent book, and offers glimpses of the writer Banks is to be, but it's just, well, off somehow. Too-pat characters. Too many improbable coincidences. Too shallow, too preachy. So weird, in fact, that I've waited almost a month to write this review. I had to wait to read another Banks ([b:The Player of Games|18630|The Player of Games (Culture, #2)|Iain M. Banks|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1166984450s/18630.jpg|1494157]) to restore my balance.
If you're a Banks fan you'll need to read it; but if you are you're not asking me for advice. To the rest of you: you don't need to read this one. (And if you haven't read Banks, try starting with [b:Against A Dark Background|422452|Against A Dark Background|Iain M. Banks|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1174599757s/422452.jpg|809748]. That still shines out as my favorite. I'm on a Banks kick, though, and am eager to find out if it survives rereading).
Every single one of my SF-reading friends is completely berserk for Iain Banks. I am myself a mostly-lapsed SF reader, so when this book -- the first in the culture series -- came up for cheap on the kindle I snatched it right up.
This is just a terrible book. Bad writing. Slow, heavy handed, predictable plotting. Completely irrelevant tangents for hundreds of pages in the plot, and flat flat flat characters that don't really have any motivations or even, seemingly, emotions.
When I went back to my SF reading friends and said "what the hell?" every single one of them said "oh no don't read that one! Its terrible! Read Player of Games or Use of Weapons!"
So there you go. If you're interested in Banks or in the Culture books go elsewhere first.
One star for some fairly good action scene writing, especially in the beginning, and one …
Every single one of my SF-reading friends is completely berserk for Iain Banks. I am myself a mostly-lapsed SF reader, so when this book -- the first in the culture series -- came up for cheap on the kindle I snatched it right up.
This is just a terrible book. Bad writing. Slow, heavy handed, predictable plotting. Completely irrelevant tangents for hundreds of pages in the plot, and flat flat flat characters that don't really have any motivations or even, seemingly, emotions.
When I went back to my SF reading friends and said "what the hell?" every single one of them said "oh no don't read that one! Its terrible! Read Player of Games or Use of Weapons!"
So there you go. If you're interested in Banks or in the Culture books go elsewhere first.
One star for some fairly good action scene writing, especially in the beginning, and one star for bits of humor scattered throughout. But mostly: ugh.
