jayvall reviewed The gilded years by Karin Tanabe
Review of 'The gilded years' on 'Goodreads'
This was a DNF for me. I got up to the part where Anita reveals her "secret" to the reader - which is not a secret to any reader who already read the back copy - so I don't know how anything else in the book fares, but I don't think this is for me. For one, the amount of exposition in dialogue is distractingly high. Characters speak in paragraphs telling the reader all sorts of things people wouldn't actually say in an actual conversation, which I think is just bad writing. Secondly, and maybe this is racially petty, but I feel like this should be an #OwnVoices book. I know the author is half Japanese/half white and I'm sure has her own perspective on what it's like to be that biracial-composition, I'm not sure she's the right person to be writing a story about a black woman passing for …
This was a DNF for me. I got up to the part where Anita reveals her "secret" to the reader - which is not a secret to any reader who already read the back copy - so I don't know how anything else in the book fares, but I don't think this is for me. For one, the amount of exposition in dialogue is distractingly high. Characters speak in paragraphs telling the reader all sorts of things people wouldn't actually say in an actual conversation, which I think is just bad writing. Secondly, and maybe this is racially petty, but I feel like this should be an #OwnVoices book. I know the author is half Japanese/half white and I'm sure has her own perspective on what it's like to be that biracial-composition, I'm not sure she's the right person to be writing a story about a black woman passing for white. I did find an article where she talks about feeling a sense of familiarity with how people speculated about the main character's ethnicity but I don't think it's the same and I'm not sure the propriety (for lack of a better word) of this author writing this book would go over well in 2022.