This was rather underwhelming. I've long loved 'The Monkey's Paw', but Jacobs's weird fiction is very much a minor strain in his work. Aside from 'The Monkey's Paw' and the less successful 'The Well', all the stories here are his benignly humorous tales of village life (which I found uncompelling) and of hapless sailors home from sea. These latter work better, but the overall set-up is usually that of the central characters' gullible foolishness being cheerfully and repeatedly exploited. The funniest lines are usually reserved to irrelevant prefatory asides from the narrators (Claybury's oldest villager, or the dockside night watchman), but it all feels rather dated and quaint. I might just have to find a dedicated volume of his weird tales.
Reviews and Comments
Folklorist, Surrealist
This link opens in a pop-up window
Paul Cowdell finished reading Selected short stories by W. W. Jacobs (Penguin books -- 1345)
Paul Cowdell rated Major trends in Jewish mysticism: 5 stars
Paul Cowdell rated Leon Trotsky on the Jewish question.: 5 stars
Leon Trotsky on the Jewish question. by Leon Trotsky (A Merit pamphlet)
Paul Cowdell rated Buried For Pleasure: 4 stars
Buried For Pleasure by Edmund Crispin (Gervase Fen, #6)
In the sleepy English village of Sanford Angelorum, Oxford professor and amateur detective Gervase Fen is taking a break from …
Paul Cowdell rated The boy who bit Picasso: 5 stars
Paul Cowdell finished reading The boy who bit Picasso by Antony Penrose
Picasso's ok, but no Max Ernst, so it was lovely to read this unaffected and charming little book which manages to lay out exactly what was good about him. (I reckon it's likely the best book on Picasso ever). Also, a great book for kids who want to know what's exciting and wonderful about art.
Paul Cowdell rated Falling Angel: 4 stars
Paul Cowdell rated Beyond Sleep: 3 stars
Beyond Sleep by Willem Frederik Hermans
A young geologist hungry for fame journeys to the mountains of Norway’s Arctic north on a research expedition, but soon …
Paul Cowdell reviewed Liberty or Love! by Robert Desnos
Paul Cowdell rated Mourning for Mourning: 5 stars
Paul Cowdell reviewed Fantômas (Fantômas, #1) by Pierre Souvestre (Penguin classics)
Every Man His Own Fantômas, or, Away With Nostalgia
5 stars
(The Fantômas novels are a delirious whirlwind at the centre of my life. I wrote the following text some years ago for a 'zine called Carterhaugh).
Do you know where the masked gaze of the Master of Terror first burned into you? I was in a second-hand bookshop in Balham. In Edward Gorey’s picture his cape swept over the city, and I felt those demonically empty eyes drawing me in. Gorey compared the characters to Looney Tunes cartoons, and ‘The Silent Executioner’ launched me on a night journey into sheer malicious wonder.
I was entranced.
These evil black pearls were magical and I wanted more. This was my discovery, nobody could ever have heard of Fantômas before, and I soaked up every empty coffin, every rubber-armed disguise, every deadly-perfumed flower. I was frenzied with the poison of these texts, and later with the deadly toxins of Feuillade’s films. I lived …
(The Fantômas novels are a delirious whirlwind at the centre of my life. I wrote the following text some years ago for a 'zine called Carterhaugh).
Do you know where the masked gaze of the Master of Terror first burned into you? I was in a second-hand bookshop in Balham. In Edward Gorey’s picture his cape swept over the city, and I felt those demonically empty eyes drawing me in. Gorey compared the characters to Looney Tunes cartoons, and ‘The Silent Executioner’ launched me on a night journey into sheer malicious wonder.
I was entranced.
These evil black pearls were magical and I wanted more. This was my discovery, nobody could ever have heard of Fantômas before, and I soaked up every empty coffin, every rubber-armed disguise, every deadly-perfumed flower. I was frenzied with the poison of these texts, and later with the deadly toxins of Feuillade’s films. I lived the swooning dread of the Unseizable One’s reign.
Along the way I came to realise that not only was I not, in fact, the first to succumb to his malevolent darts, but that many of the people I most admired had also written with similar frenzy of his iron grip. The early Surrealists, contemporaries of the novels and Feuillade’s films, were also swept along on their narcotic clouds. Apollinaire seems to have lifted the title ‘The Poet Assassinated’ from a customarily vicious episode in a Fantômas novel. (Such a theft is itself worthy of the Genius of Crime).
And of course this was only to be expected. I was responding to the same febrile marvels as the earlier Surrealists had.
But I began to notice another trend, too, as I became more involved with contemporary Surrealism. Liking Fantômas had been sanctioned by our forebears. It was acceptable and appropriate to admit liking Fantômas. How many people borrowed my Feuillade DVDs because they felt they ought to, and then had nothing to say about them afterwards? How many people were prepared to drop the name of Fantômas whilst clearly having no interest in his crimes? Fantômas had simply become canonical.
The canon has a dead hand, but I didn’t love Fantômas because Desnos had written a poem about him, because it was permitted. I loved Desnos’s poem for the same reason I loved Fantômas: I wanted to sweep everyone and everything away in an amoral cataclysm that was not permitted, I wanted to send an actor to the gallows in my stead so that I might achieve my terrible plans. In a world which treats us with callous contempt, Fantômas’ coldly rational and unexplained fury is the doorway to our release.
We will always make lists of things we love. We will always look behind us at doors that have already opened, but their value lies in what is still found behind them, not in who told us they were open, nor in when they were unlocked. This is no nostalgic wallow. Yes Fantômas lives, but so do such convulsive descendants as T-Bag in Prison Break, the Joker, or President Lex Luthor. Only by sending the piteous Gurn summarily to his doom will we also be able to find these new Fantômases here and now, will we be able to open new doors. To break the skeletal grip of the canon we must not admire Fantômas. We must be him.
To the sewers!