Reviews and Comments

Jack šŸ’œ

WaferBiscuits@bookwyrm.social

Joined 1Ā year, 10Ā months ago

He/Him šŸŽ‰šŸ³ļøā€āš§ļø Big fan of cozy gay romance, sci-fi, fantasy, and any kind of xenofiction. Exhausted, but happy to be here! šŸ•ŗāœØ

My longterm goal is to read every published book with a transmasc lead that I can get my grubby little hooves on. Feel free to lob stuff over in the list I’ve been growing!

Please pardon the mess - I imported my GoodReads data and it’s gonna take a lot of fiddling to get everything ship shape. 🧹

This link opens in a pop-up window

Chuck Tingle: Camp Damascus (2023, Doherty Associates, LLC, Tom)

Welcome to Neverton, Montana: home to a God-fearing community with a heart of gold.

Nestled …

Review of 'Camp Damascus' on 'Goodreads'

Absolute banger of a horror novel, and that’s coming from someone who didn’t grow up in what I know is an all-too-familiar traumatic environment for a lot of folks.

Feels like it could have used an epilogue though, to be honest. The ending is a bit abrupt.

Stephen King: The Long Walk (Paperback, 1999, Signet Group, Penguin Group)

In the near future, where America has become a police state, one hundred boys are …

Review of 'The Long Walk' on 'Goodreads'

God I love this one so much. Sometimes it’s difficult for me to read something cover to cover, but this is one of the rare ones that keeps me pushing through the eye strain. A severely underrated classic in its simplicity.

Jess Everlee: Rulebook for Restless Rogues (2023, Harlequin Enterprises ULC)

Review of 'Rulebook for Restless Rogues' on 'Goodreads'

Always love seeing more work from this author, though I think I personally prefer the first in this series. The writing itself is great, engaging and tight, but the overarching plot fell a bit flat for me. It feels like there was a lot of struggle in getting certain story beats to mesh together.

It was a fun time though! Just not necessarily a repeat.

Garry Kilworth: Frost dancers. (1993, HarperCollins)

In the Highlands, Skelter the hare led a wonderful life - browsing among the heathers, …

Review of 'Frost dancers.' on 'Goodreads'

This is an odd one. I’m usually a huge fan of Kilworth’s work, and his take on hares certainly isn’t a bad one, it just feels tonally off. I really wish he hadn’t felt the need to include such a bizarre antagonist as the harpy eagle (who you only know is a harpy eagle once you read the afterward - the narrative is intentionally vague on that). Very abrupt ending as well.

I liked it! Just not my favorite of his line-up.

Riyoko Ikeda: Claudine (Paperback, 2018, Seven Seas)

Review of 'Claudine' on 'Goodreads'

This is a weird one to review. This is a manga about a trans man created in 1979, and it was honestly more tactful than I expected it to be, but it’s still pretty old fashioned and has the usual antiquated attitudes towards trans identities that you’d expect. Really not a fan of how the narrator, a psychologist, continually misgenders Claudine despite being the only character who affirms his manhood. It makes me wonder if it’s a translation thing.

Honestly, my main criticisms aren’t even about the trans stuff though. The volume is short as hell, less than a hundred pages, yet it goes at a breakneck pace with zero time to catch its breath in-between plot points. We never really get to know Claudine at all outside of his romantic trysts.

I’d say you probably should read it as a historic piece, and Ikeda’s artwork is eternal eye candy. …

Harry Nicholas: Trans Man Walks into a Gay Bar (2023, Kingsley Publishers, Jessica)

'On the bookshelves, there was plenty of stuff on being gay, and much needed, joyous …

Review of 'A Trans Man Walks into a Gay Bar' on 'Goodreads'

This took me such a long time to read, if only from how painfully relatable so many of the author’s experiences have been to my own. I’d read one essay and then have to put it down for a handful of days. Harry does such a great job describing what it’s like to experience hyper visible invisibility.

There are so few books out there written from a gay trans man’s perspective. This is one of those precious few.

Everina Maxwell: Ocean's Echo (Hardcover, 2022, Doherty Associates, LLC, Tom)

Rich socialite, inveterate flirt, and walking disaster Tennalhin Halkana can read minds. Tennal, like all …

Review of "Ocean's Echo" on 'Goodreads'

This is a big mix of loving the characters, the writing, and the majority of world building - but the more cerebral focus on mind control and brainwashing was a tough sell for me.

Still really enjoyed my time, but a lot of it just isn’t for me I think.

Suzanne Collins: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes (2020, Scholastic Press)

The odds are against him. He’s been given the humiliating assignment of mentoring the female …

Review of 'The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes' on 'Goodreads'

I hate that I’m giving this two stars. Such a strong opening!! Yet it’s bogged down by a horrific bloated middle that just dilutes what impact there is by the end.

There’s stuff here I like. I like that Snow is as horrible as he is from the get-go. I love Lucy Gray and how we know so little about her because we’re locked in that limited 3rd person narrative. I love how you only get glimpses of who she really is through her songs. I love Sejanus and his whole conflict with his tribute. I love the revelations with the ending.

Ugh but hippity hoppity, that villain was lame. And would think! So was the game!

Man. This thing needs the fluff taken out of it to save the great opening/ending.

reviewed Mockingjay by Suzanne Collins (The Hunger Games, #3)

Suzanne Collins: Mockingjay (Hardcover, 2010, Scholastic Press)

Katniss Everdeen's having survived the Hunger Games twice makes her a target of the Capitol …

Review of 'Mockingjay' on 'Goodreads'

Ohhh dear. Oh no. Okay.

It gives me no pleasure to give this a two, but that last third demands it from me, no matter how strong the opening is.

reviewed The Missing Page by Cat Sebastian (Page & Sommers, #2)

Cat Sebastian: The Missing Page

When James learns that an uncle he hasn’t heard from in ages has left him …

Review of 'The Missing Page' on 'Goodreads'

This one is a warm hug and kiss on my forehead oh I love it so so much. You know how hard it is to find established relationship mlm? Let alone a mystery?

I hope we see more of James and Leo someday.

reviewed Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins (The Hunger Games, #2)

Suzanne Collins: Catching Fire (Hardcover, 2009, Scholastic Press)

Sparks are igniting. Flames are spreading. And the Capitol wants revenge.

Against all odds, Katniss …

Review of 'Catching Fire' on 'Goodreads'

I kind of see why I had zero memory of this book compared to the first. There are two standout scenes I really, really love, but the rest of it has already turned into brain soup.

The Katniss vs. Snow scene at the beginning is great. I love the tension, the intense rose/blood imagery that Snow gets. He’s a fun villain!

I will be forever chasing that bombshell weight of that Peeta interview reveal line as well. That hit like a truck.

But everything else is just kinda… eh? I don’t like Gale. I couldn’t tell you why. He just sort of annoys me, so the love triangle between him and Katniss and Peeta doesn’t really give me much other than a dull yawn.

However, for a YA? The pro-direct action messaging is really nice.

reviewed The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins (The Hunger Games, #1)

Suzanne Collins: The Hunger Games (Hardcover, 2008, Scholastic Press)

Could you survive on your own, in the wild, with everyone out to make sure …

Review of 'The Hunger Games' on 'Goodreads'

A delightful revisit! I forgot how good this was. Collins has a real knack for world-building. It’s no wonder that this paved the way for dozens of imitators.

Listened to the audiobook by Carolyn McCormick, who might be one of my favorite narrators out there for her touch of gravitas and vocal range for character voices (that Hamish voice?? Brilliant)

Anna-Marie McLemore: Self-Made Boys (Hardcover, 2022, Feiwel & Friends)

Stonewall Honor recipient and two-time National Book Award Longlist selectee Anna-Marie McLemore weaves an intoxicating …

Review of 'Self-Made Boys' on 'Goodreads'

Oh dear. This just wasn’t for me, but like! That’s okay. I’m not the target audience here. Take this more as a personal 2.5 stars.

This is historical YA even outside of being a Great Gatsby retelling with race/gender changes I found on the whole fitting and interesting. There is just something so inherently cool about making Jay and Nick trans.

Where points get docked, unfortunately, is in the writing quality. This book suffers from the get-go by being YA that’s inevitably going to get compared to Fitzgerald, and the book never hits a point where I found myself truly engaged. The romance just constantly fell flat to me, and the messages toeing the line to Saturday Morning Special cheesiness. Which is fine! God knows we need a little queer joy right now, but at the cost of washing down morally grey characters to facsimiles of their former selves?

Making …

reviewed A Court of Frost and Starlight by Sarah J. Maas (A Court of Thorns and Roses, #3.5)

Sarah J. Maas: A Court of Frost and Starlight (Paperback, 2020, Bloomsbury Publishing)

Feyre, Rhysand, and their friends are still busy rebuilding the Night Court and the vastly …

Review of 'A Court of Frost and Starlight' on 'Goodreads'

So it’s fanfiction, right? That she wrote for her own series?

I actually can’t help but admire this, and I’d be a hypocrite to say that I hated the concept. People who know me know that 90% of my 90+ abominations on ao3 are all tagged with ā€˜established relationship’ and ā€˜post-canon’ - this kind of sappy shit is jack catnip. I (usually) can’t get enough of it. Even the plot points feel like fanfiction! A Christmas story? Really? I have written established relationship Christmas fanfiction! I’ll admit that! I’m not above it all! Far from it!

Oh, but this is just too much. Too much sugar. Not enough spice. And I get it, as someone who very frequently writes similar shit. It’s a hard balance. The problem is that Maas’ writing style is so breakneck that she doesn’t allow herself to break from a jog to the leisurely walk that …

reviewed Shady Hollow by Juneau Black (Shady Hollow, #1)

Juneau Black: Shady Hollow (2022, Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group)

The first book in the Shady Hollow series, in which we are introduced to the …

Review of 'Shady Hollow' on 'Goodreads'

This was so charming! I found this book by chance tucked in a shop corner, and the premise alone sold me. Think cozy PBS Rosemary & Thyme, but with furries. It’s got that small town coziness to it that I really enjoy. Thankfully, the authors don’t completely rely on stereotypical bestiary characterizations, but I can forgive them for leaning on them a little.

The actual mystery is a bit typical, and you’ll probably be able to suss out the clues before Vera does, but that’s okay. The journey to the end is a fun one, and I look forward to see how the rest of the series stands.