Reviews and Comments

YouNaughtyMonsters

YouNaughtyMonsters@bookwyrm.social

Joined 10 months, 1 week ago

Mostly reading SF, but with some Graham Green and Hollinghurst in there too.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Kim Stanley Robinson: 2312 (Paperback, Español language, 2013, Orbit) 3 stars

Corre el año 2312. Los avances científicos y tecnológicos han abierto una puerta a un …

Review of '2312' on 'Goodreads'

2 stars

Overly sentimental, disjointed, and wasteful of its actual good ideas.

The storyline feels like it was made up as a way to put characters in certain situations, which in turn made it all feel contrived. On top of that, I found it very hard to care about any of the characters (bar Kirin), so whenever they were in some faux danger (it's the future no one is really in danger) I didn't even really mind the outcome. Sometimes I even hoped for the worst, they were all so entitled and lothesome.

The actual world building is fine, but it really feels like KSR put in a lot of effort and wasted it on a storyline that doesn't really deserve such a grand stage. I can see what KSR was trying to do at times, revisiting some ideas about how we see ourselves that they tried in The Wild Shore, but …