User Profile

Owen McK

bookllyfr@bookwyrm.social

Joined 1 year, 11 months ago

Librarian.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Owen McK's books

Dixe Wills: Tiny Stations An Uncommon Odyssey Around Britains Railway Request Stops (2014, AA Publishing) 2 stars

Review of 'Tiny Stations An Uncommon Odyssey Around Britains Railway Request Stops' on 'Storygraph'

2 stars

A missed opportunity. The author is self-deprecating but also distastefully deprecating of the people he encounters. It's also curiously uninformative, with no map, and no explanation that the Bootle he visits is not the large town in Merseyside.

Kate Clanchy: Some Kids I Taught and What They Taught Me (2020, Pan Macmillan) 4 stars

Review of 'Some Kids I Taught and What They Taught Me' on 'Storygraph'

5 stars

I read this book as a collective portrait of schoolchildren painted with understanding and sympathy. So I was surprised to see it criticised for dealing in stereotypes and disdain. It's true, for instance, that Clanchy writes about one pupil that 'poverty is stamped through Cheyenne like letters in a stick of rock, manifesting itself in her rotting, nineteenth-century mouth'. This isn't a gratuitous dig about a girl too lazy or stupid to brush her teeth: it comes towards the end of a chapter which faces head on issues of poverty, class, and the author's own privilege.

Is Clanchy's language clumsy? Often. Does she insist on physical and racial labels for every child? Afraid so. Did she pretend that her critics had fabricated quotes? Astonishingly, yes. And yet, this is also a book that shows sensitivity to and celebration of children's individuality.