aastha reviewed Butter by Polly Barton
Beauty standards, gender roles, internalized misogyny, and all the good things.
3 stars
Butter is the story of Rika Machida, a journalist, who starts meeting with Manako Kajii, a convicted serial killer. Rika hopes to secure an exclusive interview with Manako (or Kajiimana as she's popularly known), but ends up getting sucked into her narrative. As Kajii's truth unfolds, we get to see Riika sampling food and grapple with her own past and relationships. The book highlights patriarchal gender roles and beauty standards repeatedly. This is interspersed with interesting commentary on friendships, career, internalized misogyny, care-taking, and so on. This is not done subtly, though. That was one of my gripes with the writing/translation. I also thought that the writing could have been tighter, especially towards the end. Overall, a fun and intriguing read, but probably won't make it to my 'best of 2026' list.
Butter is the story of Rika Machida, a journalist, who starts meeting with Manako Kajii, a convicted serial killer. Rika hopes to secure an exclusive interview with Manako (or Kajiimana as she's popularly known), but ends up getting sucked into her narrative. As Kajii's truth unfolds, we get to see Riika sampling food and grapple with her own past and relationships. The book highlights patriarchal gender roles and beauty standards repeatedly. This is interspersed with interesting commentary on friendships, career, internalized misogyny, care-taking, and so on. This is not done subtly, though. That was one of my gripes with the writing/translation. I also thought that the writing could have been tighter, especially towards the end. Overall, a fun and intriguing read, but probably won't make it to my 'best of 2026' list.









