User Profile

spdrnl

spdrnl@bookwyrm.social

Joined 1 month, 2 weeks ago

This link opens in a pop-up window

Judea Pearl, Dana Mackenzie: The Book of Why : The New Science of Cause and Effect (2018)

A Turing Award-winning computer scientist and statistician shows how understanding causality has revolutionized science and …

None

This book is a popularized text regarding Pearl's work on causal theory and do calculus. It is remarkable. The book tells the tale of how causal theory has been misunderstood for long in the science of statistics, mostly by the Anglo-Saxon null-hypothesis 'gang' of Fisher, Pearson and Galton; putting in doubt a lot of 20th century social research. The book also joyfully reveals how the commonly regarded 'simple' and 'explainable' linear model has been misapplied most of the times, putting my own doubts at rest.

Accounting started in around 5000 BC in Mesopotamia. It was not until the nineties that Edward Jaynes finalized the concept of Bayesian probability. Around this time Pearl also was making his work known. Statistics in the social sciences is just getting started.

None

It has been hard to get a good overview of quasi-experimental study designs. Unlike random-control group designs, stemming from medicine, quasi experimental designs stem from different disciplines.

Quasi-experimental study designs aim to tease out causal effects in observational settings. Where random-control group designs have strong internal validity, quasi-experimental designs often have stronger external validity. For those interested, look up "Qausi-experimental study designs - paper 2: Complementary approaches to advancing global health knowledge" By Geldsetzer and Fawzi (2017).

This book first gives a step-by-step introduction of regression methods, and some do-calculus, before progressing to describing thoroughly a large set of quasi-experimental methods. As it often goes, the topic is endless, so although the set is considerable, it is by no means exhaustive; and the author makes no such claim. The tone of the book is very informal (which does not add to brevity), and provides examples in Python, R and Stata. …