Reviews and Comments

subcutaneous

subcutaneous@bookwyrm.social

Joined 4 years, 3 months ago

Deepening political imaginations.

This link opens in a pop-up window

reviewed Zimbabwe by Masipula Sithole

Masipula Sithole: Zimbabwe (EBook, 2015, Chandiwana Sithole for Rujeko Publishers (Pvt.) Ltd)

This book is about the contradictions and infighting that occurred in the Zimbabwe liberation movement …

Important work, limited in scope

A very critical & insightful work of political science/organizational theory that explains the internal conflicts among leaders of Zimbabwe's nationalist independence movement through the 1960s & 1970s. The author was a participant & so has important “insider” knowledge.

I shared plenty of quotes that I found helpful, so here are some limitations: • A fairly exclusive focus on the elites. This was presumably by design, but I'm still glad I read a book focused on the grassroots movement before this one & plan to read at least one more. • It's all a bunch of (very violently) squabbling cis men - there's not even a cursory acknowledgment of gender oppression despite the fact that I can only think of one person (Fay Chung) the author mentions at all who was neither a cis man nor one of his relatives. There's default “he” throughout in reference to political actors in the …

commented on Algeria by Martin Evans (The Making of the Modern World)

Martin Evans: Algeria No rating

Invaded in 1830, populated by one million settlers who co-existed uneasily with nine million Arabs …

In 1956, the french army forced a plane of FLN leaders headed for a secret conference (which french officials were planning to attend!) to land in Algiers instead of Tunis, arresting the leaders as soon as they exited. The book calls this the first airline hijacking in history.

Charles F. Walker: The Tupac Amaru Rebellion (2014)

The largest rebellion in the history of Spain's American empire--a conflict greater in territory and …

Does what it says on the cover

If you're interested in learning about this rebellion, the book will be interesting, & the detail+extensive notes will be helpful. If you're not, this is not one of those books that's Secretly About Something Else & you shouldn't bother.