Book_Em_Danno reviewed Into the forest by Jean Hegland
None
4 stars
I'm kind of surprised that this book is apparently in the curriculum at so many colleges. I liked it, but it was kind of hard to find and a little... simplistic. I love apocalyptic and post-apocalyptic stories, even if that is only the backdrop and not the focus of the story, so I'm giving this a four. This book seems divisive though, at least based on the reviews here. There are only two real characters, and one of them will test your patience and have you rolling your eyes. I would have been fine with the book completely changing genres and tone and having the protagonist beat her sister to death at the half way point.
The other point of contention here seems to be the ending. I agree heartily, the ending made me furious. Why did I still like the book? I really like it's anti-consumerist message/vibe. I think …
I'm kind of surprised that this book is apparently in the curriculum at so many colleges. I liked it, but it was kind of hard to find and a little... simplistic. I love apocalyptic and post-apocalyptic stories, even if that is only the backdrop and not the focus of the story, so I'm giving this a four. This book seems divisive though, at least based on the reviews here. There are only two real characters, and one of them will test your patience and have you rolling your eyes. I would have been fine with the book completely changing genres and tone and having the protagonist beat her sister to death at the half way point.
The other point of contention here seems to be the ending. I agree heartily, the ending made me furious. Why did I still like the book? I really like it's anti-consumerist message/vibe. I think the ending kind of spits in the face of that message when it's meant to do the opposite. It was incredibly wasteful, in a world of diminishing supplies. I'll end this with a compliment sandwich, two good things with something bad in the middle.
Good: There is a scene that really seems to upset uptight, prudish conservative types.
Bad: The absolute hubris of Nell implying that "maybe" she and her dumb as rocks sister will contribute/discover new things on par with the knowledge and wisdom of humanity represented in books, so it's okay to destroy books. Shut... the... fuck... up. Even if together they write something better than Shakespeare, who are they going to share it with?
Good: More Bad: I mean really, does she think they will make new medical or scientific discoveries out there alone in the forest? Books should be the new currency in that world. How dare they destroy books.