Old gods, new enigmas

Marx's lost theory

No cover

Mike Davis: Old gods, new enigmas (2018)

294 pages

English language

Published July 2, 2018

ISBN:
978-1-78873-219-2
Copied ISBN!
OCLC Number:
1014051592

View on OpenLibrary

3 stars (1 review)

"Mike Davis, recipient of the MacArthur Fellowship, has written Old Gods, New Enigmas to tackle the remaining interest of Marx's oeuvre. Although everyone agrees that proletarian agency is at the very core of revolutionary doctrine, one searches in vain for any expanded definition, much less canonical treatment. For this reason, Chapter 1 adopts an indirect strategy: a parallel reading of Marx and other socialist thinkers of the classical frame. The goal has been to find accounts of how class capacities and consciousness arose on the principal terrains of social conflict; in the socialized factory and the battles within it for dignity and wages; through sometimes invisible struggles over the labor process; out of the battles of working-class families against landlordism and the high cost of living; from crusades for universal suffrage and against war. Chapter 2, "Marx's Lost Theory," influenced by Erica Benner's work on the politics of nationalism in …

1 edition

Review of 'Old gods, new enigmas' on 'Goodreads'

3 stars

the title here is devious and would make you think this is Davis' big contribution to Marxology when its actually an unbalanced collection of four disparate essays

the main one, that grants the book its name and takes up half of it, puts a lot of granular detail, geographic, sociological and labour history on the bones of Marxist historiography from the nineteenth century to the present, and is very very good.

the second, which grants the volume its subtitle, is a proposed reading of Marx's theory of nationalism via the Eighteenth Brumaire. it's decent as a reading of that text, but the new theory never really comes together. it was interesting to see Marx and Engels' getting swept up in Prussian chauvinism during the war with France wasn't a bourgeois smear, I'll probably be returning to this if it's ever necessary for me to want to debunk Trotskyist arguments about …

Subjects

  • Criticism and interpretation