DigitalRaven reviewed Exalted: Essence by James Huggins
A broken promise
2 stars
This excited me to begin with, but Essence takes entirely the wrong method to streamline Exalted.
Because the book covers playing every single kind of Exalted, it doesn't give anywhere near enough information on the world to actually run a game without further information — there's not enough setting information to play several types of Exalted (such as the Liminals and Getimian) because everything's given in broad strokes that work for many but don't have the room for exceptions.
Rules-wise, while traits are a little simplified — fewer Attributes and Abilities, fewer and more expansive Charms — the systems themselves are mostly the same baroque nonsense that breaks everything down into checklists and flow-charts, meaning that the "simplified" version is anything but. Making a combat system that didn't require a flow-chart, for example, would have actually simplified things. So would having even fewer Charms but a real system for making …
This excited me to begin with, but Essence takes entirely the wrong method to streamline Exalted.
Because the book covers playing every single kind of Exalted, it doesn't give anywhere near enough information on the world to actually run a game without further information — there's not enough setting information to play several types of Exalted (such as the Liminals and Getimian) because everything's given in broad strokes that work for many but don't have the room for exceptions.
Rules-wise, while traits are a little simplified — fewer Attributes and Abilities, fewer and more expansive Charms — the systems themselves are mostly the same baroque nonsense that breaks everything down into checklists and flow-charts, meaning that the "simplified" version is anything but. Making a combat system that didn't require a flow-chart, for example, would have actually simplified things. So would having even fewer Charms but a real system for making them, rather than several pages of "eyeball it". Instead, Essence tries so very hard to remain compatible with Exalted 3rd edition and so can't simplify things anywhere as much as the book promises.