Review of 'The Lost Plot (The Invisible Library series)' on 'Storygraph'
4 stars
So I get speakeasies, but no bigbands? Tsk, tsk, tsk...
I've always had my misgivings about the more "chick-lit-ty" moments/episodes in the books of this series - and this one wasn't an exception. The romantic/sexual undertones of the relationship between Irene and her apprentice, Kai, were, in my mind, always a bit uncalled-for, mostly due to the social relation of teacher and pupil (as well as one being a dragon prince who is at once a lot older and probably comparatively younger than his human teacher, and who was only recently deeply traumatized). But they were there, and at least didn't feel completely forced (though there seemed other characters with greater chemistry). They culminated in the two literally getting a room at Vale's place after Kai had valiantly severed his ties to the Library shortly beforehand to save its neutrality and Irene's standing at another dragon's court, in this …
So I get speakeasies, but no bigbands? Tsk, tsk, tsk...
I've always had my misgivings about the more "chick-lit-ty" moments/episodes in the books of this series - and this one wasn't an exception. The romantic/sexual undertones of the relationship between Irene and her apprentice, Kai, were, in my mind, always a bit uncalled-for, mostly due to the social relation of teacher and pupil (as well as one being a dragon prince who is at once a lot older and probably comparatively younger than his human teacher, and who was only recently deeply traumatized). But they were there, and at least didn't feel completely forced (though there seemed other characters with greater chemistry). They culminated in the two literally getting a room at Vale's place after Kai had valiantly severed his ties to the Library shortly beforehand to save its neutrality and Irene's standing at another dragon's court, in this novel.
Personally, I'd have preferred for this romance to be tragically cut short before it really began by Kai's choice. This would also have made it a greater gesture which would have felt more in tone with how I'd perceived the character in his more serious moments. But perhaps there's a not just soppy reason for the author to keep him around in some capacity.
What I really, really enjoyed was the more detailed glances this story allowed into dragon society, showing that the side of "order" is hardly the side of the "good guys" either (in case any readers had had any illusions about that left). Any dnd-players will, of course, long have known that lawful isn't necessarily followed by good, as neither of the other two are. And we get them all neatly displayed in the main factions in this series.
I also enjoyed the setting a lot and would have wished for some more "secenery" to play a role in the story. What I missed most, were "sound-bits" - there should have been a lot more jazz, to put it bluntly.
All in all, this one felt a bit weaker than its predecessors. But it was the usual fun and quick read, and I'll continue the series in time.