Stephanie Jane reviewed The Wandering by Intan Paramaditha
Interesting premise, but the format wasn't for me
4 stars
The Wandering is an updated and most definitely adult version of the Choose Your Own Adventure story books which used to exasperate me as a child. Before you assume this will be a negative review though, let me start by talking about all the aspects of The Wandering that I really liked! The initial premise of a woman frustrated with her life who is given the fantastical opportunity - although not the most practical footwear - to tear up her roots and travel the world appealed to me greatly. I instantly connected with our unnamed heroine and found myself increasingly empathising with her as her journeys progressed.
Paramaditha takes in a wide range of influences from Dorothy's red shoes in The Wizard Of Oz to traditional folk tales, the plight of modern day refugees and the writings of Brecht. In combination, all these disparate ideas make for a lot of …
The Wandering is an updated and most definitely adult version of the Choose Your Own Adventure story books which used to exasperate me as a child. Before you assume this will be a negative review though, let me start by talking about all the aspects of The Wandering that I really liked! The initial premise of a woman frustrated with her life who is given the fantastical opportunity - although not the most practical footwear - to tear up her roots and travel the world appealed to me greatly. I instantly connected with our unnamed heroine and found myself increasingly empathising with her as her journeys progressed.
Paramaditha takes in a wide range of influences from Dorothy's red shoes in The Wizard Of Oz to traditional folk tales, the plight of modern day refugees and the writings of Brecht. In combination, all these disparate ideas make for a lot of unexpected twists and turns and, I felt, gave The Wandering a light hearted playfulness that I particularly enjoyed. Paramaditha's deft descriptions allow her to concisely create atmospheric scenarios that I was happy to go along with and to believe in, even though outside of The Wandering's world, the setups would be completely implausible!
However, although otherwise I did like The Wandering, it turns out that I still am not best suited to the Choose Your Own Adventure format. Admittedly it is less infuriating in an ebook because clicking the next page number allows an instant jump rather than all that thumbing pages back and forth, but I still find the reading to be too bitty. When I settle down with a 400-odd page book, I want to be immersed in its story for hours. I don't like to abruptly find myself at Finis half an hour later and having to reread the first chapters in order to start afresh. The Wandering would be a better choice for people who like to dip into their books, set them aside and return later. For devourers like me, it ultimately just didn't satisfy.