Erin reviewed The book of night women by Marlon James
Review of 'The book of night women' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
This is a really harrowing, violent story. Part of why it’s such a tough read is the fact that the characters have to make decisions that have high costs no matter what. Self-preservation while living by strong ideals is not possible. Many stories like to provide a convenient way out for their protagonists that allows for both, but that doesn’t happen here.
James tackles all kinds of violence here and I think is also exploring the way that violence hurts perpetrators as well. This is not to say that you feel sympathy for the white people, but Quinn especially showcases the horror of the lack of cognitive dissonance.
It’s hard to know how to feel about Lilith. It’s painful to watch her through all her phases. But I think her choices are understandable, whether or not you like them. She’s an amazing character, as is Homer.
For being called The …
This is a really harrowing, violent story. Part of why it’s such a tough read is the fact that the characters have to make decisions that have high costs no matter what. Self-preservation while living by strong ideals is not possible. Many stories like to provide a convenient way out for their protagonists that allows for both, but that doesn’t happen here.
James tackles all kinds of violence here and I think is also exploring the way that violence hurts perpetrators as well. This is not to say that you feel sympathy for the white people, but Quinn especially showcases the horror of the lack of cognitive dissonance.
It’s hard to know how to feel about Lilith. It’s painful to watch her through all her phases. But I think her choices are understandable, whether or not you like them. She’s an amazing character, as is Homer.
For being called The Book of Night Women, I expected more about more of the women. I wish I had learned more about Gorgon, Callisto, and others. The book also meandered quite a bit, which didn’t bother me too much, but I did find myself wishing there was a clearer focus or build toward the ending. Instead I felt like I got a lot of the same conversation over and over between Lilith and Homer about what was right to do or what would work or not.
Very glad to have read this one. Looking forward to reading his fantasy trilogy when the last book comes out!
