Review of 'Inheriting the Revolution' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
An interesting read, though I found myself frustrated with it at times. Being based largely on autobiographies and memoirs written by members of the titular first generation, the book primarily reflects the perspectives of that era's winners, as the author herself acknowledges. Still, her methods do enable her to tell an informative story of how many of America's enuring national myths came to be constructed and may even have been somewhat true for a time.
One thing that felt sorely lacking was Native American perspectives. While the author does occasionally note the existence of indigenous peoples and the results of westward expansion by white settlers on their societies, such references were so fleeting as to be almost insulting. Even an indigenous leader as significant as Tecumseh only apparently warranted a mere two paragraphs near the end. Perhaps if Native Americans of the time had published more autobiographies she would've thought …
An interesting read, though I found myself frustrated with it at times. Being based largely on autobiographies and memoirs written by members of the titular first generation, the book primarily reflects the perspectives of that era's winners, as the author herself acknowledges. Still, her methods do enable her to tell an informative story of how many of America's enuring national myths came to be constructed and may even have been somewhat true for a time.
One thing that felt sorely lacking was Native American perspectives. While the author does occasionally note the existence of indigenous peoples and the results of westward expansion by white settlers on their societies, such references were so fleeting as to be almost insulting. Even an indigenous leader as significant as Tecumseh only apparently warranted a mere two paragraphs near the end. Perhaps if Native Americans of the time had published more autobiographies she would've thought their experiences were more important.