Marsha Woerner reviewed People Who Eat Darkness by Richard Lloyd Parry
Review of 'People Who Eat Darkness' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
In many ways, not a standard "real crime" book, although I'm not sure I can exactly say what it is. The emphasis was on a few aspects: Lucy's life as a hostess (it seemed very similar to the role of a geisha), the life of "George O'Hara" (or whatever his name has been determined to be), the overall investigation, a little bit of reflection and criminality and the differences between Japan and "the West" in terms of expectations of people in general and criminals, and differences in the legal systems.
The other thing was a little bit about history and prejudice within Japan and Korea. As an American, I feel unjustified to even present an opinion, because our history and society is so screwed up and unwilling to admit anything wrong. But it is enlightening (wrong word, but I can't think of the right one at the moment) to actually …
In many ways, not a standard "real crime" book, although I'm not sure I can exactly say what it is. The emphasis was on a few aspects: Lucy's life as a hostess (it seemed very similar to the role of a geisha), the life of "George O'Hara" (or whatever his name has been determined to be), the overall investigation, a little bit of reflection and criminality and the differences between Japan and "the West" in terms of expectations of people in general and criminals, and differences in the legal systems.
The other thing was a little bit about history and prejudice within Japan and Korea. As an American, I feel unjustified to even present an opinion, because our history and society is so screwed up and unwilling to admit anything wrong. But it is enlightening (wrong word, but I can't think of the right one at the moment) to actually see some of what MAY have contributed to George's inhumanity.
The idea that an innocent finding can be APPEALED is so against all legal systems with which I have any familiarity (okay, that would be the ONE US system…) is just weird and wrong. As an outsider, I can have my own feelings about the verdicts, but I wasn't there. The whole thing is so confusing, sad, and unjust all around.
I do enjoy learning more about societies unlike ours and doing some comparison between outcomes in different systems. And there is consideration as to whether the Japanese culture is better in some way because of the police or whether the police is like it is BECAUSE the Japanese are better in some way because of society and expectations. Lots and lots of thoughts provoked.