Eduardo Santiago reviewed The Alchemy of Air by Thomas Hager
Review of 'The Alchemy of Air' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
Everything comes at a cost—we just don’t always know what that will be or when we’ll have to pay. Haber and Bosch saved the world from Malthusian collapse and in the process gave us both WWI and WWII, not to mention obesity, diabetes, and oceanic dead zones. (We don’t have a say in whether or not it was worth it. There are no do-overs in history, and as yet we have little visibility into parallel universes.)
This was a surprisingly enjoyable book: an (IMO) appropriate mix of history, biography, speculation, and opinion. Hager provides useful context for understanding the world of that time—the agricultural need for nitrogen, the political environment—while also weaving in the personalities involved, the technical problems solved (not technical enough for my taste, which probably means it might be just-right for yours). It’s a complex story, well woven, with nuances I was not aware of: Haber, for …
Everything comes at a cost—we just don’t always know what that will be or when we’ll have to pay. Haber and Bosch saved the world from Malthusian collapse and in the process gave us both WWI and WWII, not to mention obesity, diabetes, and oceanic dead zones. (We don’t have a say in whether or not it was worth it. There are no do-overs in history, and as yet we have little visibility into parallel universes.)
This was a surprisingly enjoyable book: an (IMO) appropriate mix of history, biography, speculation, and opinion. Hager provides useful context for understanding the world of that time—the agricultural need for nitrogen, the political environment—while also weaving in the personalities involved, the technical problems solved (not technical enough for my taste, which probably means it might be just-right for yours). It’s a complex story, well woven, with nuances I was not aware of: Haber, for instance, comes off as (a bit) less of a monster than I had previously thought. (He’s still a monster, just, I guess, more human and deserving of compassion). There’s bits of geology, biology, economics; cameo roles from Darwin and Einstein; all of it enhancing the story, none of it superfluous. Hager finishes with a what-now describing the current (ahem) fallout of the H-B system: unprecedented amounts of fixed nitrogen in the atmosphere/biosphere and the consequences thereof, which we will soon have to deal with. All of it thoughtfully presented.
Suggestion should you choose to read it: there’s a section at the end with an additional paragraph or two for each chapter, I would recommend reading each one after finishing the chapter, not in bulk after finishing the book.
