joeyh reviewed Glow by Amy Kathleen Ryan
Review of 'Glow' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
An uncomfortable read, mashed on many ick points for me, including the Lord of the Flies segment, the odd gender divided plot, and several others. If I were religious I might also be bothered by some of the anti-religious viewpoints, although in truth I enjoy seeing this treated by SF, even if it's done as heavy-handedly as it is here.
There is also an uncomfortable tension between it being YA SF, which I have been trained to not expect much scientific rigour from (all those Heinlein juviniles on Mars and Venus, etc..), and it being a generation ship story, which is a SF framing that demands at least pretty plausible science -- otherwise why bother? And the scientific slipups are just so egregious here, including unexplained instantaneous communications, while also seemingly so easy to fix.
Worst of all, it may have sucked me into reading a sequel.