mattdsteele reviewed What We Owe The Future by William MacAskill
EA 2.0, it’s (kind of) in the game
3 stars
I liked a lot of the tenants of the early effective altruists; the data driven approach to doing the most good is naturally appealing. But if this is where it leads, I think I want to get off.
The author (compellingly) makes the case that the future has the potential to be vast, which essentially means that any quantitative approach, especially around extinction, is going to fall into the trap of the Tyranny of Survival. It reminds me a lot of my days in high school debate, where every round involved nuclear war scenarios, and “a millionth of infinity is still infinity”. I rejected the premise then, and I reject it now.