Lynn reviewed American revolutions by Taylor, Alan
Review of 'American revolutions' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
The revolutionary period as taught in American schools is pure fiction, in which the entire population of ‘the colonies’ (only 13 are worth mentioning) was unified in rebellion, based on fully formed republican ideals, against a tyrannical British establishment; Indians were either mindless savages or tragic figures with no political agency or agenda of their own; and the many other parties involved - the numerous colonies north and south of the rebellious 13, for example, and the Spanish empire to the west - were non-existent.
American historians, as well as others, have tried with varying degrees of success and various levels of bias to paint a fuller picture, but Taylor has outdone them all, in my view. Evaluating this period from a continental perspective allows him to consider a far more complex - and more interesting - tale, which he tells with a refreshing lack of American presupposition and in …
The revolutionary period as taught in American schools is pure fiction, in which the entire population of ‘the colonies’ (only 13 are worth mentioning) was unified in rebellion, based on fully formed republican ideals, against a tyrannical British establishment; Indians were either mindless savages or tragic figures with no political agency or agenda of their own; and the many other parties involved - the numerous colonies north and south of the rebellious 13, for example, and the Spanish empire to the west - were non-existent.
American historians, as well as others, have tried with varying degrees of success and various levels of bias to paint a fuller picture, but Taylor has outdone them all, in my view. Evaluating this period from a continental perspective allows him to consider a far more complex - and more interesting - tale, which he tells with a refreshing lack of American presupposition and in an animated style that makes a lengthy academic work read like a storybook. Probably the best book I’ve ever read on this topic.
