Baltipink reviewed From Urbanization to Cities by Murray Bookchin
Review of 'From Urbanization to Cities' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
Well. I'm annoyed. This book was a real rollercoaster - vascilating between interesting and insufferable. You know how in high school "world" history is taught as beginning with Greeks and then moving to the English and then following the anglo men as they inhabit an america that centers on northeastern puritans? Well this is basically that history except with more complicated narratives that include a larger group of white men. Asia doesn't exist. Africa doesn't exist. Most egregiously, given the US focus, indigenous ppl don't exist. Women barely exist to note their absence. Patriarchy is in quotes. Debunked theories of how gun technology defeated indigenous ppl are stated as fact. And lord don't get me started on the Greek chapter. That said, I do appreciate the more complex picture of the European middle ages. The subtle and not so subtle digs at Marxists are hilarious. And there is much to …
Well. I'm annoyed. This book was a real rollercoaster - vascilating between interesting and insufferable. You know how in high school "world" history is taught as beginning with Greeks and then moving to the English and then following the anglo men as they inhabit an america that centers on northeastern puritans? Well this is basically that history except with more complicated narratives that include a larger group of white men. Asia doesn't exist. Africa doesn't exist. Most egregiously, given the US focus, indigenous ppl don't exist. Women barely exist to note their absence. Patriarchy is in quotes. Debunked theories of how gun technology defeated indigenous ppl are stated as fact. And lord don't get me started on the Greek chapter. That said, I do appreciate the more complex picture of the European middle ages. The subtle and not so subtle digs at Marxists are hilarious. And there is much to agree with in the overall criticisms of the state and the municipalist vision. This is a book I might recommend to a white dude who has a school taught idea of anglo American history and a spark of leanings toward direct democracy, but probably not anyone else.