Benjamin Asher reviewed Hitler by Ian Kershaw
Review of 'Hitler' on 'Goodreads'
4 stars
This was excellent. Highly informative, and so well written that it was like baiting a favorite and very cool professor into rambling about the topic of his dissertation for a long, lazy class period.
I knocked off a star for two reasons. One is that there were times that the book assumed that I knew things that I didn’t. There were phrases like “by this time, of course, Mussolini had been captured.” Um. Ok, when, how, and by whom? If it was important enough to mention, it was important enough to explain.
The other is that this telling was largely military history. There were lots of discussions about this operation or that battle, which is necessary. But I felt like I was missing the things that Hitler and his functionaries were involved in on a day to day basis. Propaganda? Politics? General management? There were people who warranted a death …
This was excellent. Highly informative, and so well written that it was like baiting a favorite and very cool professor into rambling about the topic of his dissertation for a long, lazy class period.
I knocked off a star for two reasons. One is that there were times that the book assumed that I knew things that I didn’t. There were phrases like “by this time, of course, Mussolini had been captured.” Um. Ok, when, how, and by whom? If it was important enough to mention, it was important enough to explain.
The other is that this telling was largely military history. There were lots of discussions about this operation or that battle, which is necessary. But I felt like I was missing the things that Hitler and his functionaries were involved in on a day to day basis. Propaganda? Politics? General management? There were people who warranted a death sentence at Nuremberg who were mentioned for the first time in that context. So I felt like I learned a lot about World War II but very little about Nazi Germany. Which is fine, but it wasn’t the book I was looking for.
So basically I’d say that I would absolutely recommend this book to someone interested in embarking on a serious study of Nazi Germany and World War II. I would not recommend that this be the first book they read in pursuit of that project