Teru reviewed The Scythian Empire by Christopher I. Beckwith
Scholarly rethink of classical history
4 stars
Beckwith makes a compelling case, using a vast range of sources and evidence, that of the importance of Scythia in influencing, if not outright founding, many of the Eurasian civilizations that lasted for hundreds or thousands of years. Most of the book concerns itself in establishing all sorts of evidence to back the central argument, drawing from the best of historiographical and linguistic tradition. I am certain that his work will be much debated for years and may prove to be a new starting point for better understanding of diverse fields such as Classical, Middle Eastern. Chinese and general Eurasian studies.
The book is deliberate to the point of repelling more casual readers who may want "big picture" historical overviews but this is done for the purpose of creating a watertight argument that stays well away from the wishful speculation that is often the hallmark of ancient history. Likewise, minutiae …
Beckwith makes a compelling case, using a vast range of sources and evidence, that of the importance of Scythia in influencing, if not outright founding, many of the Eurasian civilizations that lasted for hundreds or thousands of years. Most of the book concerns itself in establishing all sorts of evidence to back the central argument, drawing from the best of historiographical and linguistic tradition. I am certain that his work will be much debated for years and may prove to be a new starting point for better understanding of diverse fields such as Classical, Middle Eastern. Chinese and general Eurasian studies.
The book is deliberate to the point of repelling more casual readers who may want "big picture" historical overviews but this is done for the purpose of creating a watertight argument that stays well away from the wishful speculation that is often the hallmark of ancient history. Likewise, minutiae or in-depth analysis about Scythian society itself is mostly missing as anything without much direct evidence is treated, wisely, in a skeptical fashion. The career-long interest and patience of Beckwith has culminated in a fascinating book that promises both a revolutionary new understanding of history while at the same time staying, conservatively, to the facts available.