Back
Ta-Nehisi Coates: We Were Eight Years in Power: An American Tragedy (2017, One World) 4 stars

In these "urgently relevant essays," the National Book Award-winning author of Between the World and …

Review of 'We Were Eight Years in Power: An American Tragedy' on 'Goodreads'

5 stars

This is a remarkable and powerful book. It consists of 8 long essays, each written and published in the Atlantic during the eight years of Obama administration and all are available for free online (I had read the two of them when they were published). What make them now relevant is that each essay is preceded by a note, a short essay if you like, written at present time, in which Ta-Nehisi Coates set up the context of where America was at that particular time. At the same time he also describes how he was developing as a person and as a writer, during these eight years.

All essays are important but I particularly liked three of them. The first is the “Why do so few blacks study the civil war?” The Civil War ended slavery in America, so why blacks are not interested in studying this conflict, wonders Ta-Nehisi Coates. The American Civil War has been reduced to a dramatised sports game between white men, those from the North that led the Union and those from the South that led the Confederacy. After the war ended, Coates says, the main priority of all governments was to come together as a country and they did so by building a national myth in which the African-Americans left out. Ta-Nehisi Coates is critical in this interpretation. The civil war has shaped the American history, it goes deep in explaining the slavery and the subsequent events the followed. It is time, he says, for black Americans to look at the civil war’s history, to tell their history and to reclaim their role in it.

“The Case For Reparations” is the longest essay in the book. It is a detailed, critical, and devastating analysis of how slavery, Jim Crow, segregation and later housing discrimination, and mass incarceration, encouraged by deliberate policy decisions, created enormous disparities in wealth, health, achievement and wellbeing that was passed down generation after generation to the present day. “The sins of slavery did not stop with slavery,” writes Ta-Nehisi Coates. “On the contrary, slavery was the initial crime in the long tradition of crimes, of plunder even, that could be traced into the present day. And whereas a claim for reparations for slavery rested in the ancestral past, it was now clear that one could make a claim on behalf of those who were very much alive.”

“My President Was Black” is perhaps the most powerful of the eight essays. “Obama is a conservative revolutionary, and nowhere in his conservative character revealed more than in the very sphere where he holds singular gravity - race,” writes Ta-Nehisi Coates in this clitical text. His upbringing, biracial, and raised by a white mother and two white grandparents, shaped Barack Obama and provided him with a different view of the world than that of Coates’ upbringing. He grew up in Hawaii, removed from what most black Americans experience, that is a sort of violence and segregation. He wasn't traumatised.

The respect and indeed the awe that Coates has for Barack Obama is obvious but it doesn’t stop him for criticizing him for his somehow patronizing remarks to African-American communities. African-Americans didn’t quite prospered during his administration and one of the reasons was the limits that existed in the Obama presidency. He couldn't do all that he would like to do as president of the United States but he, nevertheless, accomplished major feats. He remade the nation’s healthcare system. He revitalised a Justice Department and he began dismantling the private-prison system for federal inmates. Obama nominated the first Latina justice to the Supreme Court, support to marriage equality, and ended the U.S. military’s Don’t Ask Don’t Tell policy.

But, his very existence inflamed America’s racist conscience. Obama’s election fueled a backlash that strengthen many of the social and political divisions in America. Race, therefore, should be central if we want to understand Trump’s rise, argues Coates. Trump led a movement that exclusively relied on racism and sexism.

Ta-Nehisi Coates’ writing is beautiful and evocative. His model is James Baldwin and like Baldwin he writes with honesty and clarity. I cannot recommend this book highly enough.