Back

reviewed Beyond Measure by James Vincent

James Vincent: Beyond Measure (2022, Faber & Faber, Limited) 4 stars

A neat but incomplete look at metrology and its evolution

3 stars

The book does a good job at describing the origins of systems of measurement and how they were devised. While it's not an exhaustive account by any means, it paints a broad picture of the processes that led to our modern understanding of measurement. More importantly, the book spends a fair amount of time discussing how society has applied and regarded these; politics and economics are closely entwined with how we measure the world.

While it's clear that the author is ultimately tracing a path towards modernity, following from near eastern thought to the scientific revolution and the enlightenment to contemporary use of fundamental forces as definitions, there is a lot that is left unexplored. There is commentary about identity and how measurements were used to justify things such as as eugenics and colonialism, while also acknowledging the positive evolution of thought, but it feels lacking if only because we are not told about competing belief systems and approaches. When we hear about land surveys being used to cheat indigenous people of their lands (and rarely preserving them) we do not hear about competing systems of measurement and worldviews.

The text is primarily Eurocentric with portions, in modern times, dedicated to advancements in the United States of America. It beggars belief that there is barely nothing worth mentioning regarding the cultural views and innovations/systems in East Asia, the Middle East, Africa or Central and South America. It is only briefly that we hear of China or the Babylonians or whomever else which, given the author's compelling examinations of Western perceptions and thought and society, makes the end result poorer than if it tried to be more comprehensive.

Add to that unnecessary first-person segments interspersed among the text that would have been better served with the more detached tone otherwise found in the text. This is best exemplified by the dedication of a large part of a chapter to an episode where the author spends time with an anti-metric vandal who is also deeply religious and a brexiter. The point about cultural clash could have been made without making the author part of the story.

Still, the book is still interesting to read on the whole. It weaves together many different times, figures, and places into an entertaining and informative narrative.