Back
Edward Ashton: Mal Goes to War (EBook, St. Martin's Press) 4 stars

The humans are fighting again. Go figure.

As a free A.I., Mal finds the war …

Goodreads Review of Mal Goes to War by Edward Ashton

4 stars

Many thanks to the publisher for providing me an advanced review copy of this book, and I'm so glad they did. This was a really, really enjoyable reading experience. It was funny, charming, action packed, and had a very interesting plot throughout. While there were some issues with character development, what was done well made up for it.

Mal is software. Well, I guess the technical term is "free A.I." or sentient AI that lives in "infospace", away from the dirty, strange humans who are currently embroiled in a vicious war. The Humanists believe human augments and invasive technology has gone too far and are fighting against the Federals, the highly augmented, government backed force that is rumored to be developing technology that will give them full control of whomever they want. The free A.I.s regard humans with a sort of pitying curiosity, but when Mal finds himself temporarily controlling a drone as the local infospace comms tower is destroyed, he has no choice but to ally with a band of true misfits to try to get back home. However, the intense dangers of being on the front lines of technologically enhanced guerrilla warfare pose threats to Mal and the humans that Mal has to travel with (and usually travel inside the heads of). But through kidnapping, sabotage, and a lot of hacking, more nefarious details about the war are revealed to Mal, and his growing fondness of his human companions start to interfere with his race back to infospace.

There was a lot here that was done really well. Firstly, the story was very interesting and was a treat to follow. It flowed very well, and the story beats were paced precisely. There were no big blocks of exposition, and only a few times where I felt the story was rushed or underdeveloped. The humor here was done well, focusing less on "ha ha" moments, but rather more of a steady amusement at the stilted AI-human interactions, silly manifestations of programming, and the unfortunate circumstances our band of friends found themselves in.

Now while I really enjoyed the character of Mal, I did find much of the other character development to be a bit lacking. Mal, who is largely disgusted by humans, for some reason takes a VERY strong liking to the first human he meets, Kaleigh. But I don't feel that the narrative really built up or justified this strong bond. Particularly because it didn't feel as if it was reciprocated at all. Additionally, almost immediately after meeting Kaleigh, they join with another human named Asher who Mal never grows to like at all, despite Asher getting them (including Kaleigh) out of several dangerous situations that should have made Mal appreciate him more. I think the problem is that we spent so much time learning about Mal and Mal's introduction to humans, that we don't really get a chance to develop deeper appreciation of his human companions, so it felt odd when Mal had any strong feelings about any of them. Even though the humans were interesting at times, when any of them were in danger, I didn't feel much as the reader because I don't feel we got to know them very well. This, however, was the perfect way to manage lesser important human characters, and I feel the narrative was enhanced by our distance from less important human characters.

But as I mentioned before, this was a small gripe I had, and overall the strengths of the book really made me enjoy the whole reading experience. I'm finding that the science fiction sub-genre of "AI/robot grows connected to humans through dangerous circumstance" is one that really works for me. If you like Murderbot, the Ancillary trilogy, Sea of Rust, Partition, or even the Tea Monk & Robot books, I think you'll like this as much as I did.