Beautiful in parts, but generally underwhelming. I only had a sense of one of the characters - the rest all blurred into each other. It did inspire me to try and brush up on my geography though.
User Profile
This link opens in a pop-up window
anna_ealasaid's books
2025 Reading Goal
5% complete! anna_ealasaid has read 2 of 40 books.
User Activity
RSS feed Back
anna_ealasaid started reading Jade War by Fonda Lee (The Green Bone Saga, #2)
anna_ealasaid reviewed Orbital by Samantha Harvey
anna_ealasaid finished reading Orbital by Samantha Harvey
Orbital by Samantha Harvey
A singular new novel from Betty Trask Prize–winner Samantha Harvey, Orbital is an eloquent meditation on space and life on …
anna_ealasaid started reading Golden Mole by Katherine Rundell
anna_ealasaid reviewed Bothy: In Search of Simple Shelter by Kat Hill
Bothy
3 stars
A bothy is a hut in the hills that provides 'simple shelter' for hikers. For history lecturer Kat Hill, staying in and researching the histories of bothies was suggestive of hope and healing during a time of painful upheaval in her personal life. Each chapter is hinged on a trip to a particular bothy in Scotland and Wales, weaving together travelogue with liberally footnoted musings on a theme, and some contextual background on the bothy itself. For much of the book the various threads all seemed to me to be a little thin and incoherent, and I would have preferred either more proper history and politics of bothies or in depth life writing, rather than a smattering of both - or at least some tighter editing. But the second half of the book improved (or maybe I grew more tolerant!) The inclusion of extensive quoting from bothy guest books over …
A bothy is a hut in the hills that provides 'simple shelter' for hikers. For history lecturer Kat Hill, staying in and researching the histories of bothies was suggestive of hope and healing during a time of painful upheaval in her personal life. Each chapter is hinged on a trip to a particular bothy in Scotland and Wales, weaving together travelogue with liberally footnoted musings on a theme, and some contextual background on the bothy itself. For much of the book the various threads all seemed to me to be a little thin and incoherent, and I would have preferred either more proper history and politics of bothies or in depth life writing, rather than a smattering of both - or at least some tighter editing. But the second half of the book improved (or maybe I grew more tolerant!) The inclusion of extensive quoting from bothy guest books over the years provided fascinating insights. The book has made me want to stay in a bothy myself at least once, and to make sure I check out the bothy book while I'm there.
anna_ealasaid finished reading Bothy: In Search of Simple Shelter by Kat Hill
anna_ealasaid set a goal to read 40 books in 2025
anna_ealasaid rated Jade City: 4 stars
anna_ealasaid started reading Orbital by Samantha Harvey
Orbital by Samantha Harvey
A singular new novel from Betty Trask Prize–winner Samantha Harvey, Orbital is an eloquent meditation on space and life on …