Reviews and Comments

David Weir

davidjamesweir@bookwyrm.social

Joined 10 months ago

I'm David, a queer Fennoscottish physicist who never has enough time to read.

Find me also at tech.lgbt/@davidjamesweir.

This link opens in a pop-up window

reviewed The boat in the evening by Tarjei Vesaas (Peter Owen modern classics)

Tarjei Vesaas: The boat in the evening (2003, Peter Owen) No rating

Many-layered, dense descriptions, deceptively fragmentary

No rating

I discovered my copy of this book again a few months ago and decided to finish reading it after maybe 13 years. It was not particularly easy going for me, even though the descriptions of nature and how humans interact with their surroundings are laden with lovely imagery. I can see why I stopped reading it many years ago, but I am also glad to have finished it.

Somehow the writing reminds me a bit of Nan Shepherd's The Weatherhouse in how it is both meaningful and beautiful, and yet hard to get into.

Now that I can read Norwegian, if I had the time I would like to try reading it in the original language to see how it works. I'd also be interested in reading more works by Tarjei Vesaas.

Sara Lindquist, Elfrida Bergman: Queering Sápmi (Paperback, 2014, Qub Förlag) No rating

I got this book out the library a while ago and only got around to starting it last month, and today I have to return it... I made it about halfway through so far. The stories inside are by turns moving, heartwarming and also a bit sad.

But there are positive threads running throughout the book: the belief that things can get better - and that they are getting better, and pride in the contributors' intersecting queer and Sami identities.

Jill Benton: Naomi Mitchison No rating

This was an excellent and highly readable biography!

I find Naomi Mitchison an absolutely fascinating person. Inspiring in some ways, of her time in others, and (she would be the first to admit) outrageously privileged. But she also - to use a metaphor repeated throughout this book - swam against the current in every stage of her life. She championed unpopular ideas or spoke uncomfortable truths. Furthermore she was prevented from pursuing a scientific career because she was a women in a British upper class household in the early 20th century.

I’ve mostly read her diaries (Among You Keeping Notes…), memoirs (You May Well Ask) and poetry (The Cleansing of the Knife), but next I want to give her historical fiction (The Conquered, The Bull Calves) and science fiction (Memoirs of a Spacewoman) a try.

Dennis Baron: What's Your Pronoun? (2021, Liveright Publishing Corporation) 5 stars

The missing word is...

5 stars

I finished reading the main part of this book a while ago, but the detailed chronology of English-language gender-neutral and nonbinary pronouns took me some more time to digest (it takes up sixty pages, a quarter of the book).

In any case, I really enjoyed it. I loved the sardonic tone deployed when discussing the rants of anti-feminists, as well as historical skeptics of gender-neutral and nonbinary pronouns.

The author argues (and one of the chapters is titled) "the missing word is 'they'", and he provides a number of arguments to support this. Most interesting (and new to me) was the journey taken by 'you' from plural pronoun to also take on the role historically held by 'thou'. I also was not aware that 'they' is from Old Norse þeir.

Language is complicated, and ultimately, I believe it should generally be left alone and allowed to evolve (but this book …

Ben Orlin: Math Games with Bad Drawings (2022, Running Press) 4 stars

Bestselling author and worst-drawing artist Ben Orlin expands his oeuvre with this interactive collection of …

Popular maths books have come a long way over the years, and that's a very good thing. I read this book as an antidote to other, weightier things – both fiction and nonfiction – that I have borrowed from the library. It is fun, humourous, and richly illustrated. I strongly recommend it, and urge you to give into temptation and try the games as you go along!

(I also got an idea for my teaching from it afterwards, but I read it for pure diversion and entertainment in the first place)

Samra Habib: We Have Always Been Here (Paperback, Viking) 5 stars

A memoir of hope, faith and love, Samra Habib's story starts with growing up as …

Readable, moving memoir

5 stars

I really enjoyed this book. The author recounts their experiences as an young Ahmadi in Lahore, fleeing Pakistan, escaping arranged marriage and discovering their queerness. I found it engaging, inspiring and deeply thought-provoking. There were several passages I read aloud to people around me because they seemed so important, or so well expressed. The book, particularly its final couple of chapters, also serves as an important reminder of the privilege that many of us white queers enjoy and take for granted.

Maggie Nelson, Maggie Nelson: The Argonauts (Paperback, 2016, Melville House UK) 4 stars

An intrepid voyage out to the frontiers of the latest thinking about love, language, and …

I finished reading The Argonauts in Oodi central library last night before returning it.

I really enjoyed this book. Not a particularly easy read for me personally, but there was a lot that resonated with me. I often find books that make reference to lots of other literature to be a bit wearing, but not this one. It's the sort of book I would like to have on my shelf to dip into from time to time, so perhaps I will buy a copy.