This is definitely my least favorite of the first trilogy, but I couldn’t bring myself to give it 3 stars to differentiate it. It’s still so much more enjoyable than others I’ve tried. So it’s a 3.5 rounded up. This one was just TOO long, so much build up, for what feels like a pretty rushed conclusion.

I was surprised by how much was wrapped up at the end of this book given the length of the series. That made it feel even more rushed. But I think the important thing to remember is that this is really more the story of Fitz than it is the story of the Six Duchies. Since he has no active role in the very end of the story, it’s condensed. For me, it’s part of the way Hobb is subverting expectations. Our “hero’s” role is less dramatic than you (or he) might want.

There are some fantastic relational moments in this one. I feel kind of vindicated about how I felt about Molly and Fitz in the second book. There are some great moments with the Fool and Kettricken as well.

I love how Hobb creates characters who are “on the same side” but have different plans or motivations that end up conflicting. Chade and Kettricken’s plans, Starling’s plans. They end up at odds with Fitz and cause a lot of pain. I think that’s really well done and adds complexity through more than just personality clashes.

I’ve heard a lot of good things about the next trilogy in the series, so I’m looking forward to that!