Reviews and Comments

Harald reads

harald_reads@bookwyrm.social

Joined 2 years, 3 months ago

Just giving this a try because Goodread sucks.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Jenny Odell: How to Do Nothing (Paperback, 2020, Melville House) 4 stars

Nothing is harder to do these days than nothing. But in a world where our …

Just didn't do it for me

3 stars

The title and premise of the book seemed appealing. The attention economy has seen a lot of, uh, attention lately, and so a book about possible escapes from it seemed promising. But I came away non-plussed. The book puts together little pieces of philosophy from a large variety of writers, ranging from Greek cynics, Aldo Leopold, Walter Benjamin, to contemporary thinkers like Donna Haraway of danah boyd. But it all seemed pretty piecemeal and non-cohesive to me. I found myself skimming many passages. Ah well, it was a quick read and I did appreciate some of the discussions of how artists define and redefine attention and perception.

James C. Scott: Weapons of the Weak (1987, Yale University Press) 4 stars

A good book for these times

5 stars

It's no coincidence that I felt motivated to read "Weapons of the Week" in 2025. James C. Scott uses his ethnographic fieldwork from a small village in Malaysia to develop a notion of resistance that goes beyond Marxist conceptions of open acts of revolutionary resistance. He points out that those are rare occurrences in history, but that one would be mistaken to ignore more subtle acts of resistance that characterize the everyday life of peasants, workers in their struggle to get by. He also effectively questions ideas of hegemony or materialist determinism by showing how the upkeep of the current order is an intricate play between local elites, peasants, and their rituals, beliefs, and traditions.

Scott published his book in 1985, and 40 years later at times feels a bit dated. Ideas that Scott develops in the book nowadays have become widely accepted. But for me that does not take …

The holidays finally gave me some quiet to finish Lee Dugatkin's "Dr. Calhoun's Mousery." It's a very readable account of the the life and work of a fascinating figure in rat and mouse research after World War II. John Calhoun used his research on crowding and population dynamics in experimental mouse/rat colonies to muse about the human condition. What do rat experiments tell us about the design of cities? about "the population bomb" in humans? Calhoun himself and those who receive his work swing back and forth between wild extrapolations from mouse to human and careful framing of the research about being only about animals. Today, Calhoun's work is all but forgotten.

M. Nolan Gray: Arbitrary Lines (2022, Island Press) 4 stars

What if scrapping one flawed policy could bring US cities closer to addressing debilitating housing …

The content overall was good, especially for people who aren't as familiar with what zoning is and isn't, and what it does and doesn't do. The structure of the book starts out well, but in the later sections of the book, repetitiveness in themes and language start to creep in. It's also a bit unclear who the audience for the book is: Is it trying to convince people who are already open to zoning being problematic to follow Gray's full zoning abolitionist project? Is it the abolitionist rhetoric employed to get proponents of zoning to give in a little and at least achieve reform?