Reviews and Comments

Andy H.

indeed_distract@bookwyrm.social

Joined 1 year, 9 months ago

Precision-seeking, but often ridiculous. The same figure as indeed_distract@wandering.shop.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Simon Jimenez: The Spear Cuts Through Water (2022)

Review of 'Spear Cuts Through Water' on 'Goodreads'

I loved The Vanished Birds more fiercely, but I think that this one made me laugh like the SICKOS guy more often, so who's to say which is better, really. Brilliant and weird, playful and bloody, and confident enough in what it's doing to put off explaining it until it has enough momentum to hurt.

Review of 'A Succession of Bad Days' on 'Goodreads'

No rating

Started slow and dense and took me a long time in the background of other things, before blossoming into something marvelous about halfway through. This is the second in a series about what might be the only relatively safe and democratic place to live in a world whose ecology has been warped by magic and whose politics have been dominated by conflicts between tyrannical wizards for hundreds of thousands of years. The first book was about going to war with the kinds of magical and social technologies you need to secure a place like that against whatever terrors want in; this one is about finding more or less prosocial ways to learn to be a wizard in community, in a universe where that's a bit like finding an ethical way to be an exposed nuclear reactor.

I'm glad these books exist. They're triumphs of worldbuilding that make no attempt whatsoever …

Review of 'Driftwood' on 'Goodreads'

To be clear, if I'd encountered this attached to a D&D campaign setting or something when I was a teenager, it would have blown my mind. As it was, though, I felt uncomfortable with its recurring trope of racial pure-bloodedness, and thought its singular emphasis on this one guy's fame and importance made the whole thing feel a bit small and claustrophobic.