I needed to input a title but really the stars say it all. Only the chapter on pensions was a bit sloggish, mostly I think, because as an American, I didn’t have anything similar and it was difficult to situate the discussion in my experience
User Profile
local area communist
This link opens in a pop-up window
Jezza's books
User Activity
RSS feed Back
Jezza reviewed Social Reproduction Theory by Tithi Bhattacharya
Jezza finished reading Social Reproduction Theory by Tithi Bhattacharya
Social Reproduction Theory by Tithi Bhattacharya
This groundbreaking collection explores the profound power of Social Reproduction Theory to deepen our understanding of everyday life under capitalism. …
Jezza started reading We Are Cuba! by Helen Yaffe
We Are Cuba! by Helen Yaffe
The extraordinary account of the Cuban people’s struggle for survival in a post-Soviet world
In the aftermath of the fall …
Jezza wants to read Fire on the Mountain by Terry Bisson
Fire on the Mountain by Terry Bisson
Fire on the Mountain is a 1988 novel by the American author Terry Bisson. It is an alternate history describing …
Jezza rated Light From Uncommon Stars: 4 stars
Light From Uncommon Stars by Ryka Aoki
Good Omens meets The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet in this defiantly joyful adventure set in California's San …
“If, for whatever historical reasons, organizations that are supposed to champion “class struggle,” such as trade unions, fail to be insurgent, it does not mean then that “class struggle” goes away, or that these struggles are “beyond class.” Indeed as Williams astutely observes, “there is not one of these issues which, followed through, fails to lead us into the central systems of the industrial-capitalist mode of production and . . . into its system of classes.”
— Social Reproduction Theory by Tithi Bhattacharya (37%)
I think this gets to a lot of current issues with “labor support” for actions or policies that don’t directly affect their workers
Jezza started reading Social Reproduction Theory by Tithi Bhattacharya
Social Reproduction Theory by Tithi Bhattacharya
This groundbreaking collection explores the profound power of Social Reproduction Theory to deepen our understanding of everyday life under capitalism. …
Jezza finished reading Stalin by Domenico Losurdo (Saggi -- 49)
Stalin by Domenico Losurdo (Saggi -- 49)
Jezza reviewed Stalin by Domenico Losurdo (Saggi -- 49)
Jezza reviewed The Dawn of Everything by David Graeber
Fascinating archeology, disappointing pedagogy
3 stars
Content warning Their thesis statement, as I can glean it, which they only state in the last chapter.
Deeply frustrating book. their central thesis, which is fine, if a little anticipated by most post-modern political theory, is that there are no socially or technologically deterministic reasons for hierarchies or states and that their development is a historical accident. The pedagogy of the book — going through a hundred examples before stating their thesis — makes it a bad read, politically speaking (even if I largely agree with them), and worse learning. On the other hand, archeology and anthropology is fascinating.
If you’re looking for the premise and getting tired of the literature review aspect, this is what I wrote to a friend in a similar place:
There are three fundamental freedoms (the freedom to choose your society or social relations, the freedom to leave, the freedom to disobey. These are contrasted with the fundamental forms of domination, which are monopoly of violence, monopoly of information, and individual charisma. The emergence of these forms of domination hinder the exercise of freedom culminating in first, second, and third order “states”, the last of which encompasses or employs all three. However, as opposed to the stagist and/or the technologically determinist view of history, nothing about the scale or complexity of human relations and society necessitates that large groupings of human “need” a third order state in order to live fulfilling, prosperous lives.
On the contrary, there are examples littered throughout history of peoples living healthy, fulfilling, prosperous lives without any or all of these forms of domination present. That we do live in a world dominated by third order states is a historically contingent accident and later justified by western philosophy.
Jezza finished reading The Dawn of Everything by David Graeber
The Dawn of Everything by David Graeber, David Wengrow
For generations, our remote ancestors have been cast as primitive and childlike--either free and equal innocents, or thuggish and warlike. …
Jezza started reading The Dawn of Everything by David Graeber
The Dawn of Everything by David Graeber, David Wengrow
For generations, our remote ancestors have been cast as primitive and childlike--either free and equal innocents, or thuggish and warlike. …