Back
Donna Tartt: The Secret History (2004, Vintage Contemporaries) 4 stars

Under the influence of their charismatic classics professor, a group of clever, eccentric misfits at …

Review of 'The Secret History' on 'Goodreads'

2 stars

a fun read, this one. themes include false appearances, power, corruption (of the moral variety), privilege and aesthetic value amongst others. my only criticism is that the plot could have unfolded in a more tactful manner. you've probably read the kind. they usually make you think "ah, so that's why so and so happened" or "oh my god so and so was happening behind the scenes" or "the puzzle has been complete..." and the like. generally, the kind of storytelling that makes a reader appreciative of the order and amount of information revealed to them. it would have made henry's revelation (or confirmation of richard's suspicion) of their crimes at the bacchanal much more entertaining. additionally, henry's whole transformation into a tragic criminal mastermind would have been a little more satisfyingly jarring rather than badly executed.


i think the only good reference to a seemingly arbitrary past event (rather than one elaborated upon after its significance was made known to us) was at the inn. charles had found a gun and a reference to the fact that they had been shooting at francis's place much earlier in the book was made. it made the reader reminisce of a much simpler time in the characters lives which was held in stark juxtaposition to their disarray within this scene. the letter head from the italaian hotel on bunny's letter was a close contender for this position.


despite some characterization and pacing issues the writing itself was exceptionally good. if it wasn't for this aspect of the novel i would have put it down immediately but, fortunately, it was more than amusing and down right hilarious when it needed or wanted to be. of course, the thematic significance is also highlighted with skill.


all in all, it is a great book. i definitely recommend giving it a read before you attend that impulsively scheduled, mid-semester bacchanal.