Ika Makimaki rated The Great Derangement: 4 stars

The Great Derangement by Amitav Ghosh
"Are we deranged? The acclaimed Indian novelist Amitav Ghosh argues that future generations may well think so. How else to …
342.53 ppm Tāmaki-makau-rau, Aotearoa. Ngāti Te Ata land.
This is the place for the books I read, I half-read and even I don't read but think about.
You've been warned.
This link opens in a pop-up window

"Are we deranged? The acclaimed Indian novelist Amitav Ghosh argues that future generations may well think so. How else to …

"Are we deranged? The acclaimed Indian novelist Amitav Ghosh argues that future generations may well think so. How else to …
When future historians ask, 'Why didn't people take action to stop the climate crisis when they had known about it for decades', a prominent part of the answer will be the history of denial and obfuscation by the fossil fuel industry, and the ways in which people in positions of power and privilege refused to acknowledge that climate change was a manifestation of a broken economic system.
— The Climate Book by Greta Thunberg, Greta Thunberg (Page 29)
From the Chapter by Naomi Oreskes - "Why didn't they act?"
From the Chapter by Naomi Oreskes - "Why didn't they act?"
The rapidly escalating climate and ecological crisis is a global crisis: it affects all living plants and beings. But to say that all of humankind is responsible for it is very, very far from the truth. Most people today are living well within the planetary boundaries. It is only a minority of us who have caused this crisis and who keep driving it forward. This is why the popular argument that 'there are too many people' is a very misleading one. Population does matter, but it is not people who are causing emissions and depleting the Earth, it is what some people do - it is some people's habits and behaviour, in combination with our economic structures, that are causing the catastrophe. The Industrial Revolution, which was fueled by slavery and colonization, brought unimaginable wealth to the Global North, and in particular to a small minority of people living there. That extreme injustice is the foundation that our modern societies are built upon. This is the very heart of the problem. It is the sufferings of the many that have paid for the benefits of the few. Their fortune came at a price - namely oppression, genocide, ecological destruction and climatological instability. There is a bill for all this destruction that has not yet been paid. In fact, it hasn't even been added up; it is still waiting to be invoiced.
— The Climate Book by Greta Thunberg, Greta Thunberg (Page 19)
Greta Thunberg doesn't miss.
Greta Thunberg doesn't miss.
Parts of it feel already a bit dated. Specially the assumption of the jump from hunter/gatherers to agricultural societies assumed as a given and linear progression (this idea is heavily disputed in The Dawn of Everything, Graeber and Wengrow).
But overall a good overview and questioning of the educational structures we have built and subject our kids to. It proposes some clear actionable strategies to reinvent education and centre the children's experience and interests. Personally I found it to be a great tool in my family's journey into unschooling.
Parts of it feel already a bit dated. Specially the assumption of the jump from hunter/gatherers to agricultural societies assumed as a given and linear progression (this idea is heavily disputed in The Dawn of Everything, Graeber and Wengrow).
But overall a good overview and questioning of the educational structures we have built and subject our kids to. It proposes some clear actionable strategies to reinvent education and centre the children's experience and interests. Personally I found it to be a great tool in my family's journey into unschooling.

How Children Learn is a nonfiction book by educator John Caldwell Holt, first published in 1967. A revised edition was …

How Children Learn is a nonfiction book by educator John Caldwell Holt, first published in 1967. A revised edition was …

"Are we deranged? The acclaimed Indian novelist Amitav Ghosh argues that future generations may well think so. How else to …

In this ambitious successor to The Great Derangement, acclaimed writer Amitav Ghosh finds the origins of our contemporary climate crisis …
Modern capitalism, the most unique, as well as the most pernicious, social order to emerge in the course of human history, identifies human progress with bitter competition and rivalry; social status with the rapacious and limitless accumulation of wealth; the most personal values with greed and selfishness; the production of commodities, of goods explicitly made for sale and profit, as the motive force of nearly every economic and artistic endeavour; and profit and enrichment as the reason for the existence of social life. No society known to history has made these factors so central to its existence or, worse, identified them with “human nature” as such. Every vice that, in earlier times, was seen as the apotheosis of evil has been turned into a “virtue” by capitalist society.
— Remaking Society by Murray Bookchin (20%)
Bookchin knows.
Worth the hype. It's a short, enjoyable and quite fun read. Clever and well written. Would recommend. :)
Worth the hype. It's a short, enjoyable and quite fun read. Clever and well written. Would recommend. :)