Niklas reviewed My Thoughts Exactly by Lily Allen
Review of 'My Thoughts Exactly' on 'LibraryThing'
4 stars
In spite of the weird words where Allen states that she did not enjoy a privileged upbringingâshe didâthe rest of this book is thoroughly enjoyable.
Itâs the degree Iâm interested in: the things in my life that changed events, upended things, upset the cart. Sometimes, these were external events I had no control over: my son, George, was born three months prematurely, but had already died inside me; I was stalked for seven years and felt my life threatened by someone with a severe mental illness, then witnessed his trial â Iâve been through episodes of mental ill-health myself, so I felt for him despite what he did to me, as itâs no fucking picnic; Iâve been sexually harassed as an adult by someone in a position of power and whom I trusted; and I was taken advantage of sexually as a young teenager by men who should have known better. Turns out, itâs an all-too-common experience. (Me too.) Sometimes it was me, myself, who wreaked havoc on my own life, as youâll see. (Self-destructive.)
She seems to be entirely honest about what she writes; as with any autobiography, itâs always important to see whatâs behind the obvious. You wonât get that here. This is more a recant to a friend than it is deep introspection, more Courtney Love than Simone de Beauvoir, but if we were to criticise Allen for that, weâd miss the point: sheâs a modern-day storyteller, and a very good one at that, so just shut up and get on the ride, yes?
I started singing as a child at school, but discovered music as a young teenager and kept it close to me from then on. I read. I keep notebooks. Iâve got a good eye. I collect textiles, love colour, and decorating or doing up a house doesnât faze me at all. I exercise but Iâm not a natural athlete. Iâm a swimmer. Iâm strong. I can be tough. Iâve been broken. Iâm opinionated. Iâm a people-pleaser. Iâm a narcissist. Iâm co-dependent. I donât always like being alone, though equally there are times when I canât bear company. Iâm spoilt. Iâm needy. I can be a hypocrite. I contradict myself. I can be cold.
I feel itâs refreshing to read self-deprecation unless itâs written in vain. The above is a good glug of honesty, albeit not nuanced; but thatâs the start of the book, and reading it for the second time is actually a taster into what Allen has explained previously.
Allen writes a lot about her family, and focuses on her dad, or really, about his absence from everybodyâs lives. She brands him a liar, a narcissist, and truthfully, sheâs not the only one to have done that; Alex Jamesâs first autobiographical book contains quite a lot of tomes from the days of Keith Allenâs partying with him.
Grouchoâs was part of my life from a young age. I knew the phone number off by heart by the time I was six. How depressing is that? The name rings true for me too, because it really is a club I do not want to be part of, and yet they will have me as a member. God knows, Iâve spent enough time there over the years, enough even to be barred entry for a month at a time once or twice over the years, after being caught doing drugs in the loo. But when we were young, a room there was Dadâs idea of childcare. Dad didnât do much of that â childcare, that is. Mostly, when it came to Dad looking after us, it was cancellations, crap excuses and disappointments.
Dad didnât like it when Mum got together with Harry. He was horrible about him. He called Harry a dick. I know, Dad. You left Mum in a ditch with three kids to look after, and Harry, who everyone adores and who doesnât take cocaine, took on the family you abandoned without complaint. What a dick.
Allen is good at writing straight-up stuff without obvious intent to shock the reader; itâs frankly refreshing to read her calling her dad a dickâbecause he obviously has been one.
Her terse words on how she started out with songwriting, becoming immersed with what she does very well on the lyrical front, is indicative of her entire outgoing career, really:
Similarly, for our English lessons, when he taught us The Day of the Triffids, written by John Wyndham, who had lived close to the school, Mr Langlands took us outside and into the landscape to read passages from the book, so we listened to the words while sitting in the very vegetation that had inspired Wyndham. That helped teach me that storytelling could be painterly and visual, and itâs a lesson I use in my songwriting still. I donât want to write about a particular single feeling, or settle on one refrain in songs â âOh, my heart is broken; gee, how I love youâ¦â, etc. Instead, I try and build up layers of details â itâs Tesco carrier bags that the little old lady in âLDNâ is struggling to carry; itâs his parentsâ basement where my URL Badman sits at his computer, in the song of the same name â to deliver a whole picture and tell a contained story.
The second song I wrote was âLDNâ. That came easily, too. Iâd spent all this time in London sitting in Falafel King or in cafés on the Portobello Road or on the bus or tube, watching people and how they interacted with each other. Iâd fill in the gaps and create stories around the people I saw, making up conversations I imagined theyâd be having, as if I was watching a movie that I was making up as I went along. Iâd think about what their houses looked like, or whether they had kids, and what theyâd have for dinner. I had this fantasy thing going on all the time in my head, and once I started writing, it all came out.
On how she got her first record deal, which rings sweetly:
The deal that Dad got was with a record company owned by Warner called London Records, but I donât think he did it just as a way to make money. I think the idea to make a record together was a way for Dad to show that he loved and believed in me. I think it was his way of trying to give me something. I think it came from a nice place. I think. Other times I think maybe he got a big finderâs fee and signing up his seventeen-year-old daughter to be a singer was about cash, but mostly I dismiss that thought and go with the nicer, better, sweeter version. Thatâs how I got my first record deal â it was an act of nepotism, pure and simple.
That build-up and last sentence says quite something about her writing overall, I feel. Good. Itâs sorely needed.
The following paragraphs says a lot to me of how many women see many men, and sadly, for good reasons:
George was fit and quite a bit older than me. He was exactly my type. I assumed he was making a pass at me. I thought I was in. But George didnât come on to me. He took me back to his house and made up a bed for me on his sofa. When I woke up the next morning, he poured me a cup of coffee. âI hope you donât mind,â he said, âbut I went through your phone while you were asleep and called your mum. I told her that I donât think you should be here any more. Iâm going to take you to the airport and put you on a plane back to London.â And thatâs what he did. It was an amazing thing. It was one of the first times a man had done something nice for me without any sexual agenda. George was a life-changer. I didnât know that then, and I didnât think about him much after that, but he held on to my number and nearly two years later he rang me at exactly the moment I needed to hear from him, then helped reset me on my track forwards. Sometimes, you meet the good guys.
Gordon Ramsay has always been a dick. And a bitch.
Gordon Ramsay: âWhat do you think of Lily Allen? Chick with a dick?â Cheryl Cole: Nods. Laughs. Nods again. Oh my fucking God! Cheryl Cole basically called me a chick with a dick on national fucking television. When âSmileâ was released as a single, one of the B-sides was a song called âCheryl Tweedyâ. Itâs a jaunty little number about my own self-loathing. The first verse goes: âI wish I had qualities like Sympathy Fidelity Sobriety Sincerity Humility. Instead I got lunacy.â The chorus goes like this: âI wish my life was a little less seedy Why am I always so greedy? / Wish I looked just like Cheryl Tweedy.â
And yah, sheâs entirely right about the nepotism and dominance of the major record labels (may they die, including streaming platforms like Spotify):
The point is, those awards are hollow. Theyâre about what deals and negotiations are going on between the labels. Itâs their show. Thatâs why you saw Skepta and Stormzy being nominated in 2017, but neither one winning a single prize. What do you mean they didnât win? Which other artist has had a bigger impact on the music industry over the last few years? No one! But that would be a waste of a prize or two as far as the big companies are concerned, because both those guys are independent rather than signed to any major record label.
Also, brilliant point made:
Still, at least they donât have to take half their clothes off to perform on those kinds of shows. I donât think Stormzy has ever had to deal with a comment about his arse.
Itâs brilliant to read her words on sex and self-worth, something that all can connect to (or, nearly all):
Thatâs what I did with all the guys I dated. I attached myself to them as firmly as I could, and as stickily as theyâd allow. Iâd convince myself that they were right for me and we were meant to be together, even if really we would have been better off as friends. Indeed, Iâve stayed friends with all my ex-boyfriends, which might prove my point. I was confused at the beginning of my sexual life about my own desire for other people. Often, if a guy fancied me, that was enough for both of us. My self-worth was low and so being fancied, which I translated as being wanted (and thus loved), felt intoxicating enough to agree to sex.
Allen writes sensitively, and straightforwardly striking about her stillborn first child:
In the morning the midwife said, âYouâre crowning. We can see the babyâs head. Not long now.â Then some time later â I donât know how long, maybe it was five minutes, but it could have been five hours, she said â âThe cord is wrapped around the babyâs neck. There was a pulse. Now there isnât. There is no pulse now.â
That meant the baby was dead. He wasnât out of my body yet, but they knew. They called it. He was dead. I could feel his little head between my legs. But my contractions werenât strong enough to push him all the way out. The doctors told me they couldnât pull him out with forceps or use a ventouse because doing that would rip him apart. He was too small, too underdeveloped for those things. The only thing to do was pump me full of drugs to help increase my contractions. I was warned that these drugs would make me very sick and that it would still take time for them to work.
My baby was dead. I couldnât escape the enormity of that. He was physically stuck, not quite outside me, not safe inside, either. I was physically stuck, too. I hadnât been able to keep him inside me and now I couldnât deliver him. For ten hours between my baby dying and me getting him out, I entered a realm Iâd never been to before. It is a realm I cannot describe or revisit, even if I wanted to. The sickness I was experiencing was consuming. I felt knocked out. I felt not human.
George was born that evening. He was cleaned up and wrapped in a blanket and a little hat, and Sam and I held him for a long time. We took photographs. Weâd had our little babe and he was in our arms; itâs just that he wasnât alive. Then the doctors put me to sleep. In the morning, we were discharged. The hospital needed the bed.
The reactions to the video for Allenâs single âHard Out Hereâ, a comeback single of sorts, and mainly, Allenâs reaction to them, is astoundingly good (I feel):
I was upset by the negative reactions to âHard Out Hereâ. One woman, a poet called Deanna Rodger, performed a spoken word response to the video and uploaded it online. She cried while she performed her piece because Iâd upset and offended her so much. I was livid when I first saw Rodgerâs video, because I felt like she was using me to make a bigger point (a point I agreed with, that I was trying to make and get across in the video). But once Iâd got over feeling defensive, I listened to what she had to say. What she said made me adjust and shift my thinking. It made me realise that my naïvety over the video and the reaction to it was the privilege of being a white woman. As a result, I began to read about intersectional feminism. I began to learn more and I began to look at my output in a more responsible and considered way. Thatâs what happened in the long term: I learned and grew from negative experiences, my fuck-ups, and the shit I had to deal with.
Then, honestly as usual, Allen writes about blowing up on tour:
I have a history with drugs and alcohol, but in terms of sex, up until my Sheezus tour, I was pretty straight. I didnât masturbate and barely watched porn. Sure, Iâd shagged around a bit, but I didnât consider myself promiscuous. But I left our family Arizona therapy session angry, sad and confused. So hereâs what I did: I started exploring sex, and not with my husband. I started sleeping with people on my tour.
And this is why she writes lyrics like drinking water is to a lot of people:
Who knows why a marriage falls apart? There are the reasons that you know, that you can talk about, and then there is the more mysterious part of it: the part that means you donât, or canât, try hard enough to fix things. The part that goes: All I wanted was to be with you forever but now I canât be with you at all.
She writes a lot about the debilitating trauma brought on by being stalked by Alex Gray, a mentally disturbed person, for seven years; he broke into her home, confronting her as she woke up. I canât even imagine that trauma.
Thoughts on people attacking on Twitter:
I donât react well to being bullied or backed into a corner. I donât want to be silent. Thatâs why I keep tweeting â even though my Twitter feed is hijacked by people tweeting hateful comments. Often this takes the form of men consistently tweeting the same three charges against me to prove their point and win their argument. The charges are 1) Iâm a bad mother; 2) Iâm famous because of my dad; and 3) Iâm stupid. In other words, what they do is belittle me.
Because if you shout at someone enough and tell her sheâs a dumb woman who wouldnât be anywhere without her dad, then sheâll shut up, right? Example: I was tweeting about a Theresa May speech recently and someone tweeted: âOi, Lily, can I smell your privates?â I replied: âYeah, sure, but you might want to wait because Iâm on the blob.â My Twitter feed went mad. People were outraged. âHow can you say that?â the tweets went. âNo wonder everyone hates you,â they went on, âwhen you talk like that.â I was, like, What planet are we on? This guy just asked to sniff my privates but I mention my period and Iâm the one who is disgusting?
Overall, the book is a very easy read with moments that made me go yikes, regardless the fact that most of us go through them at times; Iâm not talking about appearing at the brit awards, but rather everything that isnât swill and fill; this is a deeply human book, and itâs likeâ¦more like reading lyrics by Lykke Li than Lily Allen, I feel, but I doubt that many people can produce a book like this, so swathed in self-awareness, in a very, very good way. Montaigne would have turned glad, I think.