Reviews and Comments

Patrick Johanneson

pjohanneson@bookwyrm.social

Joined 1 year, 5 months ago

part-time prevaricator

This link opens in a pop-up window

reviewed The Just City by Jo Walton (Thessaly, #1)

Jo Walton: The Just City (2015) 4 stars

Created as an experiment by the time-traveling goddess Pallas Athene, the Just City is a …

Very good

4 stars

Athene sets up a city based on Plato's Republic and peoples it with freed slave children, worker robots, and men and women from up and down the timeline. About five years in, Socrates shows up and starts asking some difficult questions.

If you haven't read Plato, that's OK. I haven't, either, and I still understood the book.

One warning: there are a couple scenes of sexual violence, and Jo Walton doesn't shy away from it.

Now I need to read the sequels.

Gene Wolfe: The Land Across (Paperback) 4 stars

A Kafka-esque travelogue

There's a lot going on

4 stars

But then there's always a lot going on in a Gene Wolfe novel. This was my first read, and it's going to require additional read-throughs for me to pick up on some of the puzzles. But even on a surface level, this book is very "all things to all people".

Grafton, an American travel writer (well, that's what he claims to be, and why wouldn't we believe him?), travels to an unnamed country in Eastern Europe, the land across the mountains, intending to write the first travel book about the nation. Very quickly he becomes entangled in a Kafkaesque bureaucracy, a haunted house, at least one love triangle, a buried treasure, and a Satanic cult. Strange figures come and go—for example, was that Dracula?

To quote one of the police officers in the first chapter:

"All maps are wrong. If the [enemies] come, they will be lost."