Bodhipaksa reviewed Her Smoke Rose Up Forever by James Tiptree, Jr.
Good, but a long-ass book
5 stars
My first encounter with James Tiptree Jr. (aka Raccoona Sheldon, real name Alice Sheldon) was many years ago, in a short story collection a friend was reading for a university course. The story, "The Screwfly Solution," stuck with me. It was brutal, laying bare the potential within men for violence against women, and the way they'll use religion to justify it.
It wasn't until many years later that the internet revealed the story's title and author — those details having long faded from my mind.
I bought "Her Smoke Rose Up Forever" a few years ago, but only just got around to reading it.
I do recommend it. Sheldon was a ferociously talented writer and storyteller. I loved most of the stories in here. I was surprised to find that The Screwfly Solution had a bit of an old-fashioned feel to it. It felt like something from the fifties or …
My first encounter with James Tiptree Jr. (aka Raccoona Sheldon, real name Alice Sheldon) was many years ago, in a short story collection a friend was reading for a university course. The story, "The Screwfly Solution," stuck with me. It was brutal, laying bare the potential within men for violence against women, and the way they'll use religion to justify it.
It wasn't until many years later that the internet revealed the story's title and author — those details having long faded from my mind.
I bought "Her Smoke Rose Up Forever" a few years ago, but only just got around to reading it.
I do recommend it. Sheldon was a ferociously talented writer and storyteller. I loved most of the stories in here. I was surprised to find that The Screwfly Solution had a bit of an old-fashioned feel to it. It felt like something from the fifties or sixties, but was written in the early 70's. I was also surprised to discover that apparently Sheldon invented the cyberpunk genre, with "The Girl Who Was Plugged In," written in 1973. The key elements of cyberpunk — a dystopian future with a sharp divide between the rich and poor, people glued to screens, inhabiting bodies remotely, tech jargon, a breathless narration style — are there. I'm not sure why she's not given credit as the inventor of the genre.
It's a BIG book. The longest story is really a novella. It took me two months to get through the whole damn thing, with a long spell where it seemed I would never reach the end of the novella. It's good, but I tired of it. Sheldon can be very brutal, and her view of the relations between men and woman can be (although isn't always) bleak. It was partly that that slowed me down.
I'd recommend this as a book to read not all at once, but in installments. Read other books, and between them read one or two of the stories from here. It'll be well worth it, because this is excellent science fiction.