Reviews and Comments

subcutaneous

subcutaneous@bookwyrm.social

Joined 4 years, 3 months ago

Deepening political imaginations.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Jamie Berrout: Essays Against Publishing (EBook)

Five essays that form a critique of publishing and call for its abolition in order …

Unsatisfying but straightforward

Glad a short book like this exists & hope to find more. Not as analytically incisive as hoped. Not much historical perspective. The u.s.-centrism comes across as unintentional & therefore uncritical. One cool thing is an essay that actually talks practically about how the author runs her press, so it's not entirely polemic & theory. Author's style feels kinda radlib-y overall.

reviewed Queen of the Conquered by Kacen Callender (Islands of Blood and Storm, #1)

Kacen Callender: Queen of the Conquered (EBook, 2019, Orbit)

On the islands of Hans Lollik, Sigourney Rose was the only survivor when her family …

An intensely violent fantasy / murder mystery

This was a very, very violent book - there is a lot of physical, emotional, & sexual violence. I don't feel "gratuitous" is the right word for it, though, especially after reading the interview with the author that was helpfully included in the back of the ebook, because it confirmed they were thinking of the same themes I was while reading. I found it took me some time to get used to the descriptive style, but once I did I was more or less swept into the pace of events. I found the concluding twist to be well-prepared & felt like the scope was appropriately expanded to set up the next book. Let's see how it goes.

Karen Lord: The Best of All Possible Worlds (Hardcover, 2013, Random House)

Karen Lord’s debut novel, the multiple-award-winning Redemption in Indigo, announced the appearance of a major …

Intriguing & occasionally confusing. Reads as somewhat episodic & came away with a belief that this would have worked better split into a 26-episode anime than a novel with no images. Much deeper than the publisher's blurb, which casts the central relationship as a tired trope even though it really didn't feel like one, at least not to me. Still haven't decided whether or not to read the sequel.

commented on Zimbabwe's Guerrilla War by Norma J. Kriger (African studies series, #70)

Norma J. Kriger: Zimbabwe's Guerrilla War (1991, Cambridge University Press)

Studies of revolution generally regard peasant popular support as a prerequisite for success. In this …

The tone of this book is relentlessly [social] scientific and analytical, presented in an "objective" and "unemotional" style. This, honestly, means that it's important to step back every now and then, because the focus of the work - peasant experiences of trauma amidst a revolution, frequently at the hands of the revolutionaries they're working to support - is intensely subjective and emotional. I don't think it's wrong that the author takes this approach, it's just important to keep in mind what exactly is being described. The material is, arguably, necessarily presented analytically, because what kriger is trying to do is correct a gap in a field of social science (the study of peasant revolutions / guerrilla wars generally and the one that took place in Zimbabwe particularly) that makes its flawed claims on "scientific" grounds. And the project, actually placing the voices of peasant "masses" at the center rather than …