Reviews and Comments

t o d d w a r n e r

tw@bookwyrm.social

Joined 2 years, 4 months ago

I farm. I write. I am. I hope to be.

— "The road to hell is paved with works-in-progress." —Philip Roth

My favorite books: errantruminant.com/blog/favorite-books/

This link opens in a pop-up window

Hananah Zaheer: Lovebirds (2021, Bull City Press) 5 stars

Lives laid bare …

5 stars

"Our books became ash, then dust, years ago. The girl looks a little younger than my son, maybe ten, not old enough to remember books, schools, our lives before this life. I can hardly remember what came before. Before hurts so bad it's not even a memory."

This short story collection is bold. Penetrating. Each story a story of lives laid bare. So stunningly well written.

Alan Gratz: Ban this book (2017) 5 stars

"A fourth grader fights back when From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler …

kids band together to push back on idiocracy

5 stars

Banned in a Florida school on 5/20/2024. I immediately purchased it. Of course.

Excellent middle grade novel about students finding their strength and learning a harsh lesson about the real world and the awful (and not so awful) people who fill it.

The characters are vibrant and relatable and the author teases out a narrative that is so creative and nuanced. I am forever impressed when authors reach deep and somehow find their childhood voice so effectively.

This book touches upon a host of thoughtful topics and I can't recommend it enough.

David Grann: The Wager (EBook, 2022, Doubleday) 4 stars

On January 28, 1742, a ramshackle vessel of patched-together wood and cloth washed up on …

a stunning account

4 stars

An incredible account from the author of Killers of a Flower Moon. I'm in awe of the work required to collate and then articulate this story almost as much as the events themselves.

The Wager is a harrowing tale of perseverance, discipline, brutality, hubris, and survival that illustrates and brings to life humanity at its extremes.

ridiculous and fun

3 stars

A fellow writer handed me this book. She chuckled and said, "You only have to read the first chapter."

Well. I read the first chapter. Then the rest of the book. I know it was supposed to be clumsy and bad, but … I actually kinda liked it. Ha!

Is it often ridiculous? Oh yes. Like, Hallmark movie ridiculous, with enough melodrama to make a romance writer blush. The opening scene alone took WTF? to 11. Did the novel always make sense? Not a chance. Were there plot holes? Yup.

But ...

The writing at the line level mainly was pretty darn good. Zooming out, the structure was solid, and the pacing was on point. And the characters … at least some of them were interesting.

All this book needed was an editor with the power to say "No."

So. Fun read. Don't expect a lot and you may enjoy …

Michelle Min Sterling: Camp Zero (Hardcover, Atria Books) 3 stars

In remote northern Canada, a team led by a visionary American architect is break­ing ground …

clever, unique, makes you think

3 stars

Recommend. Let me start off with that. It didn't wow me (hence three versus four stars), but I find this a very unique read with a fascinating voice. The concept is compelling, and the principle characters are folks you really want to sit with and explore.

Most of the other characters, though, even the important ones, get short shrift. The narrative is more than a bit uneven here and there as well, but the pacing is great and the book starts off really strong.

The science: The author needed to spend a bit more on verifying the science. Even some relatively basic things, she misses the mark (insect drones are male. always. oil is not explosive. etc.).

BUT!

Great story, nice and twisty with an unexpected ending that in retrospect is perfect. I really enjoyed this.