297 pages
English language
Published Aug. 6, 2015
When the murals painted on the walls of her Brooklyn neighborhood start to change and fade in front of her, Sierra Santiago realizes that something strange is going on--then she discovers her Puerto Rican family are shadowshapers and finds herself in a battle with an evil anthropologist for the lives of her family and friends.
Unbelievably disappointing. Amazing concept with flat characters and a poorly thought out plot. It read like a first draft, so maybe my issue is with the editor more than the writing?
There's some really excellent, clever use of the magical plot to draw meaningful metaphors for racial identity, white privilege and the disempowerment inherent in telling someone else's story for them. By about midway through the book however that metaphor gets increasingly ham-fisted without developing, and the extended action sequence becomes tedious. I would highly recommend reading this book, but I wouldn't fault anyone for stopping midway.
Cookie-cutter YA urban fantasy, adequately written. The fact that it centers a non-white, non-male perspective adds quite a bit of charm, but in the end not enough to redeem it from mediocrity.
I feel bad not giving it more stars because it incorporates a ton of great political commentary (on topics like cultural appropriation, gentrification, street harassment, police brutality, toxic masculinity... there's even a teen lesbian couple) in a way that feels very genuine and unforced. And the world and premise are very unique! While the ideas are there, the level of sophistication needed to pull it all together is not. I was actually expecting to learn it was Older's first novel.
I'm glad it got published, I hope plenty of impressionable kids read it, and I will say that for $2 I got my money's worth.
Sierra is an amazing artist. She has been asked to paint a mural on an abandoned building in her neighborhood. There is a lot of street art around her but lately she's been noticing that they are starting to fade. Then one day she sees a mural change in front of her and start to weep.Her grandfather had a stroke soon after her grandmother died but now he is agitated and wants Sierra to know that he is sorry for... something. Her mother seems to know what he means but shuts Sierra down every time she asks. Some of her grandfather's friends point her towards another artist at her school for answers before they start to disappear themselves.The writing in this book was amazing. Contemporary Brooklyn is a character as much as a setting of this book. Older shows the joys of living in this neighborhood with dance clubs and …
Sierra is an amazing artist. She has been asked to paint a mural on an abandoned building in her neighborhood. There is a lot of street art around her but lately she's been noticing that they are starting to fade. Then one day she sees a mural change in front of her and start to weep.Her grandfather had a stroke soon after her grandmother died but now he is agitated and wants Sierra to know that he is sorry for... something. Her mother seems to know what he means but shuts Sierra down every time she asks. Some of her grandfather's friends point her towards another artist at her school for answers before they start to disappear themselves.The writing in this book was amazing. Contemporary Brooklyn is a character as much as a setting of this book. Older shows the joys of living in this neighborhood with dance clubs and vibrant art as well as the problems of street harassment of teenage girls and the specter of police brutality. I've never been impressed by New York City at all but this book almost made me feel like it would be an interesting place to be. Seriously, salsa thrash metal? Yes, please.
The cast of characters was inclusive without it coming across as forced for the sake of inclusiveness. There is a lesbian couple. Most of the cast are Latina(o). There are both male and female characters who are important parts of the story and the significant secondary characters range in age from teenagers to elderly.There are discussions about racism in the community. Sierra remembers a time when she surprised herself by apologizing for her dark skin. Her aunt is tells her that she shouldn't date a Haitian because you don't want a boyfriend whose skin is darker than the bottom of your foot.If this was a contemporary novel it would be nearly 5 stars. But, this is a fantasy story and that aspect was not as strong for me. The idea of being able to make your art come alive when necessary is good but the stakes of the conflict never felt high. It felt like something bad was going to happen but it wasn't clear what that was supposed to be.If you like the idea of art featuring in urban YA fantasy you can also check out these titles.The Summer Prince by Alaya Dawn Johnson"The lush city of Palmares Tres shimmers with tech and tradition, with screaming gossip casters and practiced politicians. In the midst of this vibrant metropolis, June Costa creates art that's sure to make her legendary. But her dreams of fame become something more when she meets Enki, the bold new Summer King. The whole city falls in love with him (including June's best friend, Gil). But June sees more to Enki than amber eyes and a lethal samba. She sees a fellow artist.Together, June and Enki will stage explosive, dramatic projects that Palmares Tres will never forget. They will add fuel to a growing rebellion against the government's strict limits on new tech. And June will fall deeply, unfortunately in love with Enki. Because like all Summer Kings before him, Enki is destined to die."Ink by Amanda Sun"On the heels of a family tragedy, the last thing Katie Greene wants to do is move halfway across the world. Stuck with her aunt in Shizuoka, Japan, Katie feels lost. Alone. Then there’s gorgeous but aloof Tomohiro, star of the school’s kendo team. How did he really get the scar on his arm? Katie isn’t prepared for the answer. But when she sees the things he draws start moving, there’s no denying the truth: Tomo has a connection to the ancient gods of Japan, and being near Katie is causing his abilities to spiral out of control. If the wrong people notice, they'll both be targets."Truthfully, this one was a little too "He's SO DREAMY!!!!!" with no actual explanation of why so I DNFed it.I received this book as a gift from my OTSP Secret Sister as part of my Easter box. The cover is gorgeous. I'm going to read more by this author because I love his writing.
My Easter box from my #otspsecretsister. I was just thinking about this book last night.
A photo posted by @dvmheather on Mar 25, 2016 at 3:32pm PDT
