An easy read, a light introduction
3 stars
After hearing Freud's work referenced so heavily, I read Beverley Clack's book with a hope to understand what Freud actually thought about matters such as transference, the death drive, and so on. In a way, I got what I wanted, but I was also left wanting more.
The first part of the book which describes Freud's life and his relationships with important people in his life is by far the part that I found most useful to my personal effort to envision Freud. The detail that he had an difficult professional relationship to men, but an open and collaborative one with women, was surprising - and maybe a little bit endearing? The tender feelings don't go far, though - not when the details of the ways in which Freud's perspective has often failed to note the abuse and the horrific entrenched practices directed at young women at the hands of …
After hearing Freud's work referenced so heavily, I read Beverley Clack's book with a hope to understand what Freud actually thought about matters such as transference, the death drive, and so on. In a way, I got what I wanted, but I was also left wanting more.
The first part of the book which describes Freud's life and his relationships with important people in his life is by far the part that I found most useful to my personal effort to envision Freud. The detail that he had an difficult professional relationship to men, but an open and collaborative one with women, was surprising - and maybe a little bit endearing? The tender feelings don't go far, though - not when the details of the ways in which Freud's perspective has often failed to note the abuse and the horrific entrenched practices directed at young women at the hands of men who controlled their fate.
Reading this book as anything other than a cis man may give rise to thoughts about the failings of psychotherapy. However, I am also convinced that the book - and Freud's work, in general - is worth reading, in no small part for the usefulness of understanding the emergence of ideas which later shaped a better, more egalitarian exploration of ideology and the self.