The inheritance of loss

Stephanie Jane reviewed The inheritance of loss by Kiran Desai

A worthwhile read

5 stars

According to my Goodreads, I first read Inheritance of Loss in 2009 and a few events in the story did seem familiar as I got to them, but I couldn't remember how it would all end so enjoyed immersing myself in the tale again. Desai has a beautifully rich style of writing which really brings her views of rural Himalayan India and immigrant New York to life. No one in this book has it easy whether they are truly poverty-stricken or stuck in between Indian, Nepali or colonial worlds.

For me, some of the saddest characters were those desperately clinging to remnants of a superficial British past despite its total unsuitability, and those denied a homeland by the British who didn't care who gained when they left. Desai's descriptions of the decaying house in which the Judge, Sai and the Cook exist, the barely there shacks where Gorkha families live, …

According to my Goodreads, I first read Inheritance of Loss in 2009 and a few events in the story did seem familiar as I got to them, but I couldn't remember how it would all end so enjoyed immersing myself in the tale again. Desai has a beautifully rich style of writing which really brings her views of rural Himalayan India and immigrant New York to life. No one in this book has it easy whether they are truly poverty-stricken or stuck in between Indian, Nepali or colonial worlds.

For me, some of the saddest characters were those desperately clinging to remnants of a superficial British past despite its total unsuitability, and those denied a homeland by the British who didn't care who gained when they left. Desai's descriptions of the decaying house in which the Judge, Sai and the Cook exist, the barely there shacks where Gorkha families live, and the grim accommodations of illegal New York workers are heart-rending. There is a thread of careless violence that joins many of the characters, each trampling others to get ahead even when the gain is slight and, often, easily lost again.

Inheritance of Loss isn't a happy book to read, but is very worthwhile to experience even though it is another book which has left me with a bitter taste at British Empire dreams - we did mess up a lot of the globe and the repercussions still ripple.

LuisVilla reviewed The inheritance of loss by Kiran Desai

Review of 'The inheritance of loss' on 'Goodreads'

3 stars

Makes you ache for the beautifully drawn characters, but without driving them forward much.

AliCorbin reviewed The inheritance of loss by Kiran Desai

Review of 'The inheritance of loss' on 'Goodreads'

3 stars

A novel that somehow manages to be both humorous, and depressing. The writing was excellent - poetry almost, or an embroidery of the setting. The characters, not so much. They felt like stock characters that never grew or developed. None of them were particularly likable - indeed they ranged from clueless and naive to downright nauseating. But it's possible that this novel was never intended to be about the characters themselves, but more the setting - a depiction of a particular place and time. And one that was utterly foreign to all of us.

GG reviewed The inheritance of loss by Kiran Desai

Review of 'The inheritance of loss' on 'Goodreads'

3 stars

This was my most recent book club book, and at our meeting a number of people expressed not being huge fans because they felt like the book never really went anywhere, and they weren't exactly sure what it was supposed to be about. I am of the view that this was the whole point of the book. Although I didn't love the book, there are a number of fantastic passages that absolutely nail aspects of the human experience and are very well-written, and I think it that on the whole the book accomplishes the author's intent.