chadkoh reviewed Star Wars: Twilight Company by Alexander Freed (Battlefront)
Review of 'Star Wars: Twilight Company' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
I was leery about picking up a book based on a video game, but I needed to feed my Star Wars habit in prep for the film.
This book has a lot going on. There is an ensemble cast, some who interact, and some who do not, some whose storylines jump back and forth in time. That is a lot of motivations to keep track of, especially when there are about 30 battles that take place... Which comes to another structural problem with this book: some battles are covered in depth, but most ignore the "show don't tell rule"... Exposition should not be a stylistic choice.
The thing that put me over the edge to get this book was the narrator, Jonathan Davis, who is brilliant. He does a good job here too, though having sound effects and background sounds throughout the entire 14 hours of this book was a …
I was leery about picking up a book based on a video game, but I needed to feed my Star Wars habit in prep for the film.
This book has a lot going on. There is an ensemble cast, some who interact, and some who do not, some whose storylines jump back and forth in time. That is a lot of motivations to keep track of, especially when there are about 30 battles that take place... Which comes to another structural problem with this book: some battles are covered in depth, but most ignore the "show don't tell rule"... Exposition should not be a stylistic choice.
The thing that put me over the edge to get this book was the narrator, Jonathan Davis, who is brilliant. He does a good job here too, though having sound effects and background sounds throughout the entire 14 hours of this book was a bit much... Though I was thankful for some of the musical queues, otherwise I would not understand what the characters were feeling.
There are some positives: I learned a lot about the day-to-day life of a rebel soldier, which was pretty nice.
This book is okay, and deserves 2 stars, but JD did a good job and it IS Star Wars, so I gave it 3.