English language
Published Oct. 29, 2009 by Haikasoru.
Koushun Takami's notorious high-octane thriller envisions a nightmare scenario: a class of junior high school students is taken to a deserted island where, as part of a ruthless authoritarian program, they are provided arms and forced to kill until only one survivor is left standing. Criticized as violent exploitation when first published in Japan--where it became a runaway best seller--Battle Royale is a Lord of the Flies for the 21st century, a potent allegory of what it means to be young and (barely) alive in a dog-eat-dog world.
It’s really good and a fast read despite it’s length. It’s also really incredibly bloody so watch out for that. I really enjoyed it and it’s kinda crazy to see the early literary precursor for like fortnite and PUBG
Read it.
42 students, one island--fight to the death until one is left standing. Man was this a ride.
Out of the 42, Eight or so carry most of the main focus of the story, with the most time and plot:
Group 1: Shuya Nanahara (Guitar player--Rock n' Roll!, and ex-baseball star), Noriko Nakagawa (The girl Shuya's best friend is in love with), and Shogo Kawada (Scary looking guy with scars and a tough reputation). All they want is to get out of the game with their lives and killing as few people as possible.
Group 2: Shinji Mimura (Mr. Perfect at school--smart, athletic, and a winner with the girls), and Yutaka Seto (the class clown). All Shinji wants is to beat the system and save his best friend Yutaka, even if it means saving his friend from himself.
Group 3: Mitsuko Souma (The bad girl of the class) and …
Read it.
42 students, one island--fight to the death until one is left standing. Man was this a ride.
Out of the 42, Eight or so carry most of the main focus of the story, with the most time and plot:
Group 1: Shuya Nanahara (Guitar player--Rock n' Roll!, and ex-baseball star), Noriko Nakagawa (The girl Shuya's best friend is in love with), and Shogo Kawada (Scary looking guy with scars and a tough reputation). All they want is to get out of the game with their lives and killing as few people as possible.
Group 2: Shinji Mimura (Mr. Perfect at school--smart, athletic, and a winner with the girls), and Yutaka Seto (the class clown). All Shinji wants is to beat the system and save his best friend Yutaka, even if it means saving his friend from himself.
Group 3: Mitsuko Souma (The bad girl of the class) and Kazuo Kiriyama (The bad boy of the class). These two don't team up, but they're the definite heavy hitters of this game--they're playing it hard and out to win.
Group 4: Hiroki Sugimura (Mr. Determinator). Hiroki's got a goal and nothing is going to stand in his way, friend or foe.
Granted, the above isn't completely accurate--they're just the ones that stood out the most as I was reading. Just about every character gets a moment to shine, or a small sub-plot to themselves told almost vignette style through the main four stories above. Whether it's a few scenes, or even just a few pages--you feel for them.
I think that's what's the strongest about this book. Through the violence, the romances, the deaths, and the saves--I managed to care in one way or another about all 42 of the students--whether it was cheering someone who got what was coming to them, sniffling over the sad, or just flat out gripping the pages in excitement during the action and the tension.
In addition, I love how over the top the book got as it steadily headed toward the finale. From realistic violence, all the way to machine gun showdowns and car chases--it really covers the entire spectrum. Even the randomness of weapon assignments (and seeing who made the best of the 'worthless' ones) was almost fun at times (One student got a sickle, and the other a fork, and don't get me started on the kid who got a machine gun). There's a little bit of everything and I think some of the deaths will really surprise you. It holds nothing back.
I loved every minute of it, even as the students numbers counted down at the end of each chapter. The end had a nice twist to it, and I was cheering them on the whole way.
Romance, drama, friendship, loyalties, humor, and gore--Battle Royale had a bit of it all.
Highly recommend. <3
Since my earliest youth I have weird vivid and recurring nightmares. One theme is being hunted for sport, having to find and kill my friends or be killed. Not long ago I finally dared to read [b:The Hunger Games|2767052|The Hunger Games (The Hunger Games, #1)|Suzanne Collins|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1326003698s/2767052.jpg|2792775] by Suzanne Collins. It fit in with my dreams, and that was disconcerting. But it was an elegantly written book that made you think. I liked it (the first one) I really did. It did give me some kind of 'closure' or 'background' to my dreams, even though that may sound strange. So when I found out that people where mentioning this book, Battle Royale, and that it looked way too much like The Hunger Games, I wanted to read it. And I liked it, a lot. But let's discuss that.
The bad:
1. Translation
This books translation is awfull. I hope that there …
Since my earliest youth I have weird vivid and recurring nightmares. One theme is being hunted for sport, having to find and kill my friends or be killed. Not long ago I finally dared to read [b:The Hunger Games|2767052|The Hunger Games (The Hunger Games, #1)|Suzanne Collins|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1326003698s/2767052.jpg|2792775] by Suzanne Collins. It fit in with my dreams, and that was disconcerting. But it was an elegantly written book that made you think. I liked it (the first one) I really did. It did give me some kind of 'closure' or 'background' to my dreams, even though that may sound strange. So when I found out that people where mentioning this book, Battle Royale, and that it looked way too much like The Hunger Games, I wanted to read it. And I liked it, a lot. But let's discuss that.
The bad:
1. Translation
This books translation is awfull. I hope that there will be a re-issue after The Hunger Games movie has aired. A re-issue translated by someone who can actually translate the language, idiom and such, instead of merely skimming around the edges. At times I thought Google Translator could have done a better job! Clumsy, weird choice of wording etc. It felt very unnatural at times.
So, it may be that the translation is in fact accurate and the late-writer was a half-illiterate with a publisher that didn't employ any editors or QA at all, or the translation is rubbish. Call me crazy, but I go for the latter.
2. Guts and G(l)ory
While this book is about the guts a winner of a cruel game like this one must have, it is mostly about the guts of the other players being splattered around the pages. It is one of the most gory books I've ever read. A spatter-movie in book-form. It serves a purpose and you have to view this in a cultural context (Japanese, directed at young adults) but I think it's too much. My taste is much more refined than this, and weren't it for the great storytelling, I wouldn't have liked the book at all. Now this isn't because I can't stand a drop of blood or suspense in a book. Books by [a:Bridget Wood|95774|Bridget Wood|http://www.goodreads.com/images/nophoto/nophoto-U-50x66.jpg] are for instance much more cruel and devious. But they splatter less.
A good horror movie usually is good because of abstainance of excessive gore and blood, and clever use of psychological suspense.
That is what this book lacked. The author went for quantity instead of quality in the violence department.
3. The names
Oooookay, call me an ignorant western world biased reader, but I had a hard time at the very beginning with the names. I've read a lot of books based in Japan, but come on... Yuko, Yuka, Yuki and Yukie as seperate names, most of them in the same scenes?? I had a laughing fit when I started to read the lighthouse scene. When it should've been poignant. Surely even Japanese names can have more variation to them? I really understand why the studentnumbers are necessary ;-) It's way easier to remember the numbers.
The Good
1. The Story
The author plunges you almost directly into the story, and this is a good thing. There are too many people in the story at the beginning, too many alike-sounding names. Too much pre-game-story-building would have turned me off the book.
So instead it plunges you right into the game.
The story is fast-paced and gives most of the players some background. This is nice. In The Hunger Games, everthing is so black-and-white. Katniss is good, the rest of the world outside District 12 is bad. Everyone of the contestants is out there to win against all costs.
Here in BR it's different. Almost every contestant gets a bit of backstory, explaining the persons behavior. Even the cruellest become a little bit more human, understandable. They are not excuses from their deeds, but the readers knows now why they are/act as they do/are. It makes them human.
2. Thoughtprovoking
And that is what this story is all about. Humanity. How do humans react in a horrible situation like this: trapped on an island, having to kill oneother or be killed. They are friends, they are children. Not many of us would refuse to play the game. I know I would play, if it meant a tiny chance of seeing my family again. I would loose ;-) but I would try.
We humans are no angels. Extreme situations bring out the worst ánd best in us. Unfortunately, the worst is usually the strongest.
This book, and others like it, stay with you. They permeate your thought when shopping, going outside, among other people. They make you think. Not only about the game and the contestants, but also (and more importantly) about the government. Panem et circenses, bread and games, is with todays media saturation more than ever a hot topic to be aware of. What do we sacrifice for cheap entertainment? What are we willing to accept for entertainment? What are we willing to accept for our own simple wellbeing? What are we willing to ignore as long as we have our entertainment?
This book caused a lot of unrest in Japan after it's release, more so after the movie came out. Japan is a troubled country, with an entire generation of youths spinning out of control. Having to resort to extreme measures like something like this game, may have been a real option, in a parallel universe. We see it in our 'reality shows', the lust for more and more extremes. The need to be more shocking, more real, more dramatic than the last show. The need of the media to control the population through fear. Almost everyhing on tv is about fear. It's there to both entertain and control. This is even more true on Japanese tv than on American.
I'm afraid we aren't far from seeing the first kill-shows on tv. And like the romans of yore, most of the people would only demand more blood. And gore. And guts. The stringy bits.
Hello copycat
Well, I have to confirm that Suzanne Collins really copied a lot of this book. When you've read both, it's hard to miss the the similarities.
It is more than just the premise. She can spin a beautiful story about being inspired by watching tv and greek mythology. Alright, I could swallow that. I did, actually, untill I read this book.
Everything is here, with some variation. Everyting in the first two books relates to elements in this one book. Even the leg wound and (suspicion of) sepsis, the bom, the return of a former winner, the forming of groups, the strung wire across a large span of land for escaping the game, and more . It's undeniable, and the fact that she tries to deny ever having read this book or seen the movie, is unbeleavable to me.
It isn't an exact copy and from the half of the book it diverges a bit more. And, and this is important, The Hungergames has an entire different feel about it. It feels more polished, focusses on the future and media-influence instead of just government. It has more romance (however hollow that became in books 2 and 3) and is a real 'hollywood' novel. It also has a lot less violence and erm well splattered guts.
I like both of them, they complement each other. Reinforce one message. Which message that is, can differ form person to person.
Verdict:
I really liked this book. Will I re-read? I don't know. Probably not. It doesn't really have re-readability quality, like eg. [a:Steven Erikson|31232|Steven Erikson|http://photo.goodreads.com/authors/1219169436p2/31232.jpg]s books. But it is a book that will remain with you for the rest of your life.
A concern in judging translated fiction is where to place the blame for mediocre prose. Battle Royale has a magnificent premise (kids sent to an island and forced to fight to the death in order to survive) and over the 600 pages of the novel, Takami does a great job of managing a cast of dozens and providing a reasonable amount of attention and focus to all the various students on the island. But the way he tells his story, the way he describes the action and the characters, is absolutely dreadful. It reads like something I would write. But because I'm not reading the novel in the original Japanese, it don't know if Takami is to blame, or if this is an example of lazy translation.
