I love how this book takes on heavy themes of racism and ostracism with a light but never insubstantial touch. It also contains the best skewering I've yet to read of Portland/Seattle "right-on" but clueless middle-class white culture. I found the resolution at the end a little too quick, as is common in YA books, but I appreciated how it left more complexity and ambiguity at the end than is usual for YA.
I became aware of this series because the sequel was on a list of sci-fi and fantasy books by Black authors coming out in the next few months. I wanted to get into this world before the next book came out.This is a YA fantasy book that stands as a metaphor for the experiences of Black women. Sirens' voices are powerful. They have the ability to make people do things. Sirens are always Black women and the world wants them to be silenced. Recently a woman was killed by her boyfriend. He claimed it was self defense because she was a siren who was supposedly controlling him. No one knows if that was true but just the accusation may make her murder "justified." Sirens are hidden in communities who will help them pass unnoticed. Networks of people will support them and give them outlets to use their voices. The main …
I became aware of this series because the sequel was on a list of sci-fi and fantasy books by Black authors coming out in the next few months. I wanted to get into this world before the next book came out.This is a YA fantasy book that stands as a metaphor for the experiences of Black women. Sirens' voices are powerful. They have the ability to make people do things. Sirens are always Black women and the world wants them to be silenced. Recently a woman was killed by her boyfriend. He claimed it was self defense because she was a siren who was supposedly controlling him. No one knows if that was true but just the accusation may make her murder "justified." Sirens are hidden in communities who will help them pass unnoticed. Networks of people will support them and give them outlets to use their voices. The main character in this book sings in a choir where her voice is drowned out by the other girls. But recently that hasn't been enough. Her throat burns because her voice wants to break free. She can't stand up for sirens in discussions in school without risking outing herself. Her father hates the fact that she is a siren so living her life openly is not an optionSirens aren't the only magical creatures in this world. There is a gargoyle on the roof. There are people blessed with magical charm living openly. So when Tavia's best friend starts to wonder if she may actually be a mermaid (and not just play one at the Renaissance Fair) you don't know for sure if that is a viable possibility or if she is starting to have a breakdown. The book keeps you unbalanced. I'm not sure if that was deliberate or from a lack of world building.
“Black Lives Matter. Everybody knows that.” I have to respond without sounding overly excited that he’s a decent human being, so I blink a few times too many and settle on, “I mean. I don’t know about ‘everyone.’” “Nah, they know.” He nods and does a kind of shrug. “They just pretend they don’t get it or they’d have to admit that they disagree.”
The next book in the series is about one of the Mean Girls in this book. She is supposed to be in Tavia's Network but turns on her. I'm interested to see how events play out for her. This review was originally posted on Based On A True Story
Fantastic high school coming of age and black lives struggle in a myth-filled current day Portland.
It's very slow to start and I'm having trouble getting into it. I generally have trouble with YA contemporary and this feels more YA contemporary/fantasy than I'd like.
