Review of "Lilith's Brood (Xenogenesis, #1-3)" on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
My notes and highlights: anaulin.org/blog/book-notes-liliths-brood/
My notes and highlights: anaulin.org/blog/book-notes-liliths-brood/
Pros: well-written; interesting ideas; characters who were well-drawn and developed over the course of the books(s). I'll definitely be grabbing more Butler from my wife's shelf.
Cons: the conclusion(s) were extremely pat and unchallenging (particularly the third book), and ultimately the most interesting question raised by Butler (below, for spoiler-ish reasons) is very underdeveloped.
------------ Spoiler ---------------
In the book, the alien species that saves what is left of human-kind identifies that human genetics has an inbuilt, ultimately destructive conflict between intelligence and a drive towards hierarchy - the latter being something that the aliens supposedly lack. But the way this is developed was frustrating and unsatisfying to me. On the one hand, the aliens do some pretty hierarchical things - on the small scale, impregnating a human character involuntarily; on the large scale, involuntarily sterilizing the entire remaining human race (later rescinded to "only" deporting them to Mars). And …
Pros: well-written; interesting ideas; characters who were well-drawn and developed over the course of the books(s). I'll definitely be grabbing more Butler from my wife's shelf.
Cons: the conclusion(s) were extremely pat and unchallenging (particularly the third book), and ultimately the most interesting question raised by Butler (below, for spoiler-ish reasons) is very underdeveloped.
------------ Spoiler ---------------
In the book, the alien species that saves what is left of human-kind identifies that human genetics has an inbuilt, ultimately destructive conflict between intelligence and a drive towards hierarchy - the latter being something that the aliens supposedly lack. But the way this is developed was frustrating and unsatisfying to me. On the one hand, the aliens do some pretty hierarchical things - on the small scale, impregnating a human character involuntarily; on the large scale, involuntarily sterilizing the entire remaining human race (later rescinded to "only" deporting them to Mars). And on the other hand, the supposed flaw in humans - despite being an incredibly important part of the plot - is explored only shallowly, with repeated, blunt points that "hey, humans kill each other"and "humans give too much deference to tall men". Given how important this was to the book, and how potentially interesting it could have been I would really have liked to have seen it developed more - how is it that humans are so stuck on this? What is it that can't be trained out of them? And vice-versa, how do the aliens make decision other than hand-wavy "we've got a mind-meld and consensus"? This doesn't make the book unreadable, or anything, just... a lost opportunity.
Fascinating trilogy in humanity's evolution and the dissolution of gender. The narrative arc feels mostly like a family saga, which is the brilliance of the Butler's plotting. Following the growing up and adaptation of humans to new circumstances is far more exciting than any other structure could be.
I finished the whole trilogy in one go and I enjoyed this immensely. Told from the views of three characters from three generations, the story changes and evolves just as the Oankali and the Humans evolve. At first I was put off by the final part being written in first-person but then it turned out so great. I could not say which viewpoint I liked best, they are all too different. The Oankali are definitely the most interesting and most alien species I've encountered in a long time of reading Science Ficition stories.